Le 12/05/2014 14:50, David a écrit :
On May 12, 2014 8:36 AM, Fernando de Oliveira <[email protected]> wrote:
Em 12-05-2014 09:29, David escreveu:
On May 12, 2014 7:37 AM, Fernando de Oliveira <[email protected]> wrote:
Em 12-05-2014 08:05, David escreveu:
On May 11, 2014 11:10 PM, Bruce Dubbs <[email protected]> wrote:
David wrote:
Maybe I am trying to do this too late and I am missing something
obvious. How, for crying out loud, do you build and install gudev?

BLFS talks about UDev extras from systemd and the steps in the book
are very vague.  It does not explain what to download, for example,
and the link does not take you to a particular file or even a group
of files.

I'd appreciate a better explanation, because what I'm reading just
isn't clear at all.

Keeping it at about a 3rd grad level would be great.
Well for "UDev extras from systemd", perhaps you should start with the
systemd package.

It actually is a bit complex.  Is your base system lfs-7.5 or -dev?  Is
it the systemd version or cross lfs or other?

There have been a lot of changes in -dev lately but that's the nature of
a development system.

      -- Bruce
I am working from -dev.  I had a thought after I sent my email last night and 
went back to the stable instructions for a look.  That seems a good deal more 
clear.  Should I follow those steps for this?

To clarify:

LFS has gone a change from one init system "sysvinit" to hybrid one with
sysvinit and systemd, user could chose which one to boot, not both.
After some difficulties appeared along the way, it changed back to
sysvinit only. All three sere started by Bruce Dubbs, after systemd
failed to keep with the promes to keep a udev branch for those not
wanting systemd.

The first system had udev extracted from systemd, systemd itself was
never installed there, but from a few people wanting to convert from one
system to the other. For this one, gudev had to be extracted from sytemd
with very specific instructions first devided by Bruce.

The second system had only systemd which provided udev even when
sysvinit was being used, again, by Bruce.

The third, which we think is going to last as long as eudev survives to
systemd, is using now eudev. It was being used before in LFS only by Ken
Moffat.

So, there are three different possibilities.

Depending on which LFS you use, a different approach, source tarball and
set of instructions is necessary for gudev.

Therefore, our replies depend on what is your system: before systemd or
with systemd. I am ruling out eudev (after systemd), because it was
yesterday or the day before, that we turned to eudev, without systemd.
l
If you are using a book that has in Chapter 6:

Udev-208 (Extracted from systemd-208)

then it is not with systemd.

I am not using systemd.  I have been installing from the dev book but I see 
that the stable book uses udev-208.  The documentation for building gudev in 
the stable book is much clearer.

Yes, but even if you are not using it, if it is installed, the
instructions cannot be the ones from the stable book.

As I said, I am installing from dev.  But the instructions for building gudev 
are clearer in the stable book. So can I use them?
I think there is some misunderstanding here. There is an _LFS_ dev book, and a _BLFS_ dev book. What counts is what you installed in _LFS_. Since the beginning of March, the _LFS_ dev book has gone through the cycle: - udev from systemd -- eudev (very short time) -- systemd (lasted a few weeks) -- back to eudev (very recent).

If you installed udev from systemd, the instructions in the stable _BLFS_ book are OK. If you installed systemd, then the current instructions in the dev _BLFS_ book must be used. If you installed eudev, well, there are no instructions in any _BLFS_ book right now...

Regards
Pierre

--
http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-support
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html
Unsubscribe: See the above information page

Reply via email to