Ken Moffat wrote:
On Tue, Jul 15, 2014 at 11:00:17AM -0500, Bruce Dubbs wrote:
Michael Shell wrote:
On Mon, 14 Jul 2014 17:08:35 -0500
Bruce Dubbs <[email protected]> wrote:

It's not really useful. I think I calculated the space saving as less
than 20M.


Years ago, could you imagine ever saying such a thing?! Why, that's
almost two dozen 3.5in floppies right there. LOL!

I think so it will go with regard to music files - uncompressed will
become the norm of the future and we will be back closer to the format
of the CDs of the 80's than that of the mp3 decades.

The compression for audio is significant.  You can easily get 6-1
compression.  Additionally, the size of audio files.  The audio files I have
are quite modest. Only 735M of .ogg files.  Others have many GB. Compression
becomes more important with the size of the data.

   -- Bruce

  That is what flac is for :)  Typically, it seems to use between 60%
and 70% of the space for a wav file - so, nothing like the space
reduction that you see with MP3, but it is reversible.

  On a good day (not too much electrical/wireless interference on the
mains) I can hear the benefit of 24 bits in _some_ 24-bit files in my
main hifi, and when I burned a CD of partly-ogg, partly-wav rips the
compressed files definitely had less going on and sounded lacking.

  A few years before that, I had ripped some CDs to ogg for use on
the amp and speakers attached to my desktops.  For those, I could
hear the difference between ogg and mpg123 at various settings, but
a middling ogg setting was "good enough" for what I was using (space
was at a premium, and my network was slow in those days).  But for
e.g. some examples of different guitars played through different
Randall (guitar) preamp options, 128K MP3 files are fine.

  At the moment I have 133GB of flac files, of which about 48GB is
high-res (from eclassical in Sweden, linn in Scotland, HighResAudio
in Germany, and also HDtracks on those occasions when I've been able
to get past the "region restrictions" for Rock albums - looks as if
HighResAudio have, or will have, most of those now).  So, I'm happy
to put my money where my mouth is for flac!

  Of course, some 44.1/16 albums are perfectly fine.  Some might even
be good enough on a much lower resolution carrier, it just depends
what you want out of it.   It is all "horses for courses".

  And no, I'm certainly not blessed with "golden ears" - I'm perhaps
borderline deaf, but I can still hear the differences even if I have
to turn it up 1 (or 2) louder for the quiet bits.  But disk space is
cheap, modern networks are faster, and many external drives for
backups seem to be fairly reliable.

I agree that the amount of compression depends on what you want. I once did some audio work for a commercial game and got about 4 hours of voice into about 200K. Classical is a completely different case.

My point above is that compression of man/info files is more effort than it's worth, but compression in other situations may be useful.

  -- Bruce



--
http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-support
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html
Unsubscribe: See the above information page

Reply via email to