On Thu, 2014-07-31 at 21:47 +0200, Armin K. wrote: > On 07/20/2014 09:16 PM, Armin K. wrote: > > Hello all, > > > > Thanks to Christopher Gregory and his work on integrating GNOME into > > BLFS, I have managed to create a pure systemd branch that is mostly > > derived from his work. > > > > While adding GNOME packages, he also managed to integrate my systemd > > notes into BLFS files and I have reused and polished that work to bring > > the BLFS and LFS systemd a bit closer. > > > > The book is available online at [1]. Some links may not work, namely for > > two patches and blfs-systemd-units because the book isn't yet in a > > standard location. > > > > You can download them from [2]. The same patches are available from the > > lfs patches project and systemd units were just created from the latest > > svn tree. > > > > While I believe I did everything that was necessary to make the packages > > work correctly on top of LFS systemd, there still may be some > > undiscovered problems. > > > > The book was made with assumption that latest LFS systemd (svn version) > > is used. It may work with 7.5-systemd too, but there are some things > > that are different since then, so I would not rely much on it. > > > > I have not tested the following things yet: > > > > sendmail - I don't use this, but have provided an unit combined from > > archlinux and fedora one. I couldn't test it since I have postfix > > installed and sendmail would overwrite it which I don't want. > > > > haveged - I wasn't aware that this package was even part of BLFS. I > > simply added a systemd unit to match the sysv script, but haven't tested it. > > > > firewalling section - I have provided a systemd unit and changed the > > location of the iptables script. It's similar enough to the approach I > > use (/etc/rc.local compatibility), but there's still a chance something > > got wrong. > > > > svn server - I had to made some assumptions about this one since I have > > never set up one. If anyone manages to get it working, I'd like some > > feedback. > > > > I have not completed / got idea about how to deal with following things: > > > > LXDE - It seems that every distro I checked is stuck at old version of > > lxsession and there is no systemd integration patch for systemd/logind > > for the one BLFS is using. If anyone gets it to work, please let me know. > > > > DHCP Client and DHCPCD don't have a section for using client binaries > > anymore. LFS Systemd switched to systemd-networkd and I dropped the > > ifup/ifdown script in favor of networkd itself. DHCP Client and DHCPCD > > were used in conjuction with them. I may need to write/find systemd > > units that can start them if needed. > > > > For the same reason, bridge-utils also lost its entire configuring > > section. systemd-networkd can handle bridge configuration just fine, but > > I lack the knowledge and time to write the instructions for that. > > > > I don't know what are the equivalents for random and netfs sysv script, > > but iirc, systemd should support network file systems out of the box and > > I saw someting regarding random seed in systemd itself, but I'm not sure > > if that's the same thing random script provided. > > > > And while I tested all things that were in my notes, it's possible that > > a (version) update since then managed to break something. If that's the > > case, let me know asap. > > > > What yet has not been merged is Christopher's GNOME work itself, but I > > believe that it will be merged soon. > > > > If everything goes well and things don't get too complicated, we can > > expect BLFS systemd 7.6 along with BLFS 7.6. > > > > Have fun. > > > > [1] http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/~krejzi/blfs-systemd/ > > [2] http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/~krejzi/ > > > > After some time, I have finally finished reviewing and polishing what > was left, and I'm proud to say that I find the book to be production > ready. The latest snapshot is available at the same location, with > patches not in BLFS svn book available in blfs-systemd-patches > subdirectory of my home directory, while the blfs-systemd-units tarball > is still available from my home directory [2]. > > This book contains 111 xml pages that were either heavily modified from > trunk/ or newly added ones - and that is without the GNOME section which > now offers full GNOME-3.12.2 Desktop Environment. > > We also offer Wayland and Weston packages, as well as their > dependencies. Doing that, we had to modify some packages in the Xorg > section, but they can be modified to omit Wayland just fine. > > There were also changes that weren't init system or wayland specific, > but a result of disagreements between maintainers in the past. The > changes include rewritten Qt4 and Qt5 instructions so they can be once > again installed alongside each other in /usr, using qtchooser to > dynamically switch between two installations. The instructions were also > simplified so that only one configure line is there and prefix can be > changed before running it. > > Other changes include splitting libva and libvdpau from Xorg section > into their rightful multimedia section, introduction of libva drivers > page, addition of libva-vdpau-driver package, as well as removal of > standalone Glamor package in favor of Xorg Server's internal one. > > -- > http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-support > FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html > Unsubscribe: See the above information page
Hello Everyone, I am glad that we have finally reached this stage of things. It has been a real pleasure working with Armin on this project. I sent Armin a private e-mail early on in this project saying that I would like to work with him on this, and I am very glad that I was correct in my assumption of being able to work with with him. It would have taken me a lot longer to have gotten the book production ready on my own, as I had to learn exactly how everything worked when integrating it into the book. I had to change directions early on as I could see that the way I had started to integrate Armin's notes and the main book was not really going to work. It made it too confusing having two separate sets of instructions on the same page. It needed to be broken out, even though it means that we are now going to have to manually make the changes to keep the main book and our version up to date. I still have a lot to learn because I tend to be too long winded in my explanations of what switches do etc. Part of that comes from my background of working in a call centre for an ISP and also part from when I was a systems administrator for a webhosting company. From the support emails people seemed to being confused as to exactly how to do things, so I tend to leave nothing out. I also wanted to add a lot more to gnome, but the development packages just are not required for end-users and really are a waste of hard-drive space if your never going to use them. I have created a build order page, which is the only page that I really was adamant that I wanted to remain in the book. The reason for this is quite simple. I find that it will be a lot easier for people to see the order that things are built in on a single page. Part of this stemmed from at least one email from a list member when Wayne gave the link to his version, about weather it should be followed in order, but mainly because the packages are not all located in the gnome-section. I still have some work to do on the build order page. I need to make sure that all packages that are in the book are listed there and are in the correct location. I stopped doing that when we were adding some more packages and removing others. My next project is to get my internal harddrive installed with the latest systemd book version with what is in the book and what is not and set up the external harddrive with working copies so that I can keep up with the next version of gnome. I have no intention of ever abandoning this project. Even if I end up having less time to do things, I do know that I will always have enough spare time to continue on once I have the environment set up. Regards, Christopher. -- http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-support FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html Unsubscribe: See the above information page
