On 2/25/21 9:18 AM, Taraldsen Erik wrote:
This is getting rather rather Telenor internal and probably is not
true for other ISP's, but here we go. Mobile Broad Band (MBB) is
handled by Telenor's Mobile division. Fixed Wireless Access (FWA) is
handled by Telenors Fixed division (the same group who does DSL,
DOCSIS and GPON). To further complicate matters, Telenor Group
(holding company for Telenor Fixed and Telenor Mobile) deiced to
launch FWA before the new value chain was ready. So we have two
versions of FWA - internally called FWA1 and FWA2. FWA1 (which you
have Nils) is not fully compliant with the regulatory definition of a
fixed access and has very limited management support (technical
monitoring, firmware upgrades etc). I'm working on the FWA2 value
chain and devices.
I'll admit it doesn't surprise me that something like that was going on,
after we got the B818 I can't recall seeing a single new FW revision.
I assume you are doing the tests on Ethernet, not wifi? I know the
B818 has some wifi issues as well. To isolate the LTE access I mean.
I am indeed running them on Ethernet. I don't actually use the B818 for
anything else than as a LTE modem, so I wouldn't know, if I could get
the thing to bridge I would. Or replace it with something else entirely
that I can control, but that doesn't seem to be an option on FWA. That
said the Zyxel looks like a better option since I assume it acts like a
bridge by default.
Yes interesting to see the signal stats from the device, but not
needed. More for my curiosity to compare with the Zyxel devices.
I dumped the raw signal stats the web interface grabs in an XML file
together with the Flent tests. Also did some upload only tests tonight
at different speeds (no VPN in play this time).
So with subscription limited to 30Mbit and probably radio head room up
to ~70Mbit downstream and 10Mbit upstream. My guess is that you will
see more latency in the upstream direction. I believe the B818 has
the very typical "1000 packets fifo, never drop" implementation.
Most likely yes. That's been my observation as well, that it generally
acts up the worst when somethings using the upstream. Not entirely sure
what I can do about that, seeing as I had to shape at 5Mbit to get rid
of the worst spikes (but not all).
For all I know there might be something to gain by adjusting the antenna
slightly, it's pointed in the general direction of the cell tower, but
we didn't fine tune it (I seem to recall it was a cold winter evening).
On that point, I would've liked to collect signal stats over time, but
the B818 seems to insist on chucking me out after being idle for a few
minutes, better known as scraping the stats with cURL
- Nils.
-Erik
------------------------------------------------------------------------
*Fra:* Cake <[email protected]> på vegne av Nils
Andreas Svee <[email protected]>
*Sendt:* torsdag 25. februar 2021 00.27
*Til:* Taraldsen Erik; Dave Taht; bloat; cerowrt-devel;
Make-Wifi-fast; Toke Høiland-Jørgensen via Cake
*Emne:* Re: [Cake] [Bloat] Fwd: [Galene] Dave on bufferbloat and
jitter at 8pm CET Tuesday 23
Ah, yeah it's fixed wireless I meant. Didn't really know how to say it
right in English.
We've got the Huawei B818-260 with an EMCOM XPOL-2 4G/5G on the wall.
Yes, we've got a 30 Mbit/sec subscription. In practice we usually see
~30 Mbit downstream and 10-15 upstream, and I believe when we first
got the B818 and antenna hooked up I measured ~70 Mbit downstream with
a subscription that didn't have any rate limitations, so I assumed we
should have a good amount of leeway if something affected the signal.
Sure, I can run some more tests tomorrow. Could also grab some signal
stats from the B818 if those are of interest.
By the way, I forgot to mention it when I posted yesterdays tests, but
those were conducted over a WireGuard tunnel with CAKE for the
downstream running on the other side. Doing that was the only way to
get the ADSL subscription we had to behave decently, it simply
couldn't handle things like Steam downloads with CAKE on a IFB device
in ingress mode, and shaping downstream this way kinda stuck.
Best Regards
Nils
_______________________________________________
Bloat mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.bufferbloat.net/listinfo/bloat
