Kresna Panggabean <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Klip-klip di youtube itu
palingan postingan para "pengemar" divingnya Gerrard. Gw sih gak pernah liat,
tapi kalo cari klip "Ronaldo diving" sih pernah liat.
Teori kalo orang ditarik kaosnya jatuh ke belakang sih bisa jadi, tapi secara
narik kaos kan pelanggaran tul gak? Terlepas jatuhnya ke depan atau ke
belakang, still pelanggaran.
Frely Pakan wrote:
soal gerard diving pa gak sih tiap orang mungkin punya versi tersendiri. too
bad, clattenburg mihak pool padahal bisa dibilang gak ada tackle dari hibbert.
kalo alasannya karena kaosnya ditarik ya jadi aneh, masa kaos ditarik ke
belakang malah jatuh ke depan.
===============
daile kresna, ngapain cape2 nanggepin "bitter" frely....:)
biasanya pinter nih frely, tapi karena udah apriori/negatif mikirnya makanya
gak heran ngomong ngaco...emang pinalti cuma karena tackle doank ya...handball
bisa, "ngeganggu" pemain lawan yang udah dalam posisi bebas nyetak gol juga
bisa..cari sendiri aturannya, biar kembali pinter...hehehehe....
biar frely dan para pengamat di milis ini ada sedikit bandingan, sedikit
kutipan dari media inggris (link-nya cari sendiri, biar pinter):
The Independent:
Seven minutes into the second half, Liverpool were level after their captain,
Steven Gerrard, was brought down by Tony Hibbert – the Everton defender was
rightly sent off, as he was clearly the last man.
The Scotsman
Both Everton dismissals were for incidents that produced Liverpool's
second-half penalties. Hibbert brought down Steven Gerrard in the box and
Neville handled on the line.
The full-back was always a yard behind and when the pair reached the box the
defender clipped Gerrard and referee Mark Clattenburg instantly awarded a
penalty on 53 minutes
Sunday Mirror:
Benitez suggested that Gerrard had paid the price for not putting his brain
into gear after Hibbert had seen red for bringing him down - to concede the
52nd minute penalty from which Kuyt cancelled out Sami Hyypia's spectacular
own-goal.
BBC Sport:
Kuyt scored from the spot after 54 minutes when Tony Hibbert was sent off for
hauling down Steven Gerrard as he raced clear on goal
lihat tuh..."brought down", "bringing down", "howling down", "right sent-off
as he clearly the last man", "as he (gerrard) raced clear on goal", "the full
back was always a yard behind". gue tetep percaya frely dan para pengamat
"bitter" lainnya masih cukup pinter buat ngertiin kalimat diatas dan
hubungannya kenapa pinalti pool itu sah...:)
ude ye...ngomongin yang lain napa, liverpool terus bikin bosen aja, toh gak
bakal ngrubah kenyataan that we are england's most decorated club (apa gue
pajang lagi ya signatur ini?...hehehe).
-omar-
---------------------------------
Bergabunglah dengan orang-orang yang berwawasan, di bidang Anda di Yahoo!
Answers
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
