So, did anyone see it?  Thoughts?  I figured the list would be abuzz.

SPOILERS



















On the whole, I was rather disappointed.  I'm not up to crafting a coherent
review, but some random thoughts.  First, the "weapons officer" floating in
space and shooting at people - that was just ridiculous.  It simply looked
completely and absolutely absurd.  I don't know whose idea that was, but
they desperately need to rethink that.  Maybe after the "refit" they can get
a control system that makes sense.

Second, this episode revealed a series that had no _depth_.  I remember the
original broadcast of _The Gathering_, and I really liked it.  As soon as I
saw it I thought it had the potential to be a really great TV show.  But
this was so simplistic.  There's the good guys (the Rangers) and the bad
guys (this mysterious alien race).  Now maybe JMS is planning on spinning us
like a top the way he did on the original series, but B5 had multiple layers
right from the beginning, and they just don't seem to be present here.

Third - a haunted ship?  I mean, what the hell?  How cliched and ridiculous
is that, really?  It was such an obvious plot device to blow the cover of
the mole (who was really obvious right from the beginning - the conspicuous
new alien race - gee, I wonder who it could be) - they couldn't come up with
_anything_ better?  It was really obvious that there was a mole, after all,
since they were ambushed at the colony planet, and no one on either ship was
even suspicious until a bunch of _ghosts_ told them?

Anyways, so I'm very disappointed.

Gautam

Reply via email to