> At 03:40 PM 3/28/02 -0800 Matt Grimaldi wrote:
> >> >>
> >> >> Look ma! A crazy person.
> >> >>
> >> >
> >> >Throwing insults is inappropriate.  If nothing else it lessens
> >> >the impact of your counterargument.
> >>
> >> Matt,
> >>
> >> Was this directed at Marvin or Kevin?    I couldn't tell......
> >>
> >> JDG
> >
> >Whoever called the other crazy.  I'm not entirely sure myself,
> >though I'd guess Kevin.
> 


John D. Giorgis wrote:
> That's funny, I consider "traitor" to these United States
> to be a worse insult than "crazy" - so I would have figured
> that you would have gone after the former insult, rather than
> the latter.
> 

I don't recall anyone calling a fellow listmember a traitor.
IIRC, in the message that prompted this someone said they
thought Bush stole the election.  The paragraph following
the insult attempts to rebut that opinion, but IMHO it lost
any ability to convince anyone BECAUSE of the insult, granting
the generous assumption that he *was* trying advance the
debate and discussion.

-- Matt

Reply via email to