Jim wrote, re: Snape:
>>Keeping up appearances, I imagine.  He uses Occlumency to hide his
>>true feelings from Voldermort, and favors Slytherin to demonstrate
>>his continuing loyalty.  Or at least that is my theory.

I replied:
>Keep your friends close and your enemies closer?  I  hadn't thought
>about that.

Jim responeded:
That's not really how I thought of it, Reggie. I was looking at it more from a standpoint of what if that little prat Malfoy tells Daddy that Snape is acting funny? It could draw suspicion.

Ah, ok, that makes sense to me.


>And it may be that he really doesn't see the problems with the
>students in Slytherin (or with most of them, anyway);
>Also, maybe Snape feels that Slytherin is a valid choice of house
>(as Dumbledore must also feel, since he hasn't gotten rid of
>Slytherin house), and why not have some loyalty to your own house?

That's probably also part of it. And of course sticking it to Harry and the Gryffindors is always a big bonus, I'm sure.

I really like the twist that Harry's dad was not exactly a likeable guy, at least with regard to how he treated Snape. It finally explains Snape's attitude toward Harry, which I always thought was a little weird given that Snape was supposed to be one of the good guys.


Harry got a lot of rude awakenings in this novel, finding out about how his dad and Sirius used to act, losing Sirius, Dumbledore acting in ways he didn't expect (although with a nice turnaround when they tried to arrest him), learning (or not learning) how girls act and react when they like someone, etc.

Reggie Bautista

_________________________________________________________________
Add photos to your messages with MSN 8. Get 2 months FREE*. http://join.msn.com/?page=features/featuredemail


_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to