In a message dated 8/16/2005 8:12:42 PM Eastern Daylight Time,
[EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
> From the choices you've made today -- ad hominem
> attacks, guilt by association, putting words into Cindy
> Sheehan's mouth, I draw the conclusion that you and your
> kind are scared shitless of her and the attention she's
> bringing to this completely unjustified war of
> aggression
So let me put my big jewish mouth into this portion of the debate. I agree
completely with Gautam here. She is saying there is a jewish conspiracy to help
Israel. That good american boys have died in the service of this conspiracy.
This is precisley the uber anti-semitic arguement that has been around for as
long as jews have been persecuted and murdered by christians. It is Jewish
bankers controlling the world bs, the blood libel (jews are supposed to kill
inocent christians for blood used in their rituals.). You make this arguement
you
are an anti-semite. Note that you can hold this belief and still be nice to
individuals ("some of my best friends are jewish") but stating this belief you
put yourself in the same camp as the monsters who have done horrible deads in
the past.
Let me ask you Nick. Do you think that we are in this war to protect Israel?
Are we in this war at the behest of a jewish cabal? If not then this view must
be repudiated. Because being against the war is not enough. I can be against
the war because I want all muslims to continue to suffer under oppressive
murderous regimes or because I think women should be suppressed. Do you side
with
me if I hold these views? If you are in contact with Cindy please tell her how
hurtful her remarks are to jews like myself who are not neocons. Please
explain her the provinence of her views. Maybe while she is on her vigil she
can
read "Constantine's Cross" to see how arguements like hers have existed for
over a thousand years and have been used to persecute and murder jews.
_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
