bug-binutils
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Messages by Thread
[Bug binutils/28697] objdump often doesn't look for separate debug files when using "build-id" style
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/28697] objdump often doesn't look for separate debug files when using "build-id" style
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/20876] objdump is not aware about the build ID method to find detached debug info
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/20876] objdump is not aware about the build ID method to find detached debug info
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/20876] objdump is not aware about the build ID method to find detached debug info
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33119] New: strip: broken symbol indices
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug binutils/33119] strip: broken symbol indices in shared libraries
martin.liska at hey dot com
[Bug ld/33115] New: error while linking during Rust crosscompiling to Solaris
petr.sumbera at oracle dot com
[Bug gas/33095] New: as fails to respect -march on riscv when it doesn't include the compressed instructions extension
genericnerdyusername at proton dot me
[Bug gas/33095] as fails to respect -march on riscv when it doesn't include the compressed instructions extension
sch...@linux-m68k.org
[Bug gas/33092] New: Internal error: assertion failure in build_modrm_byte
qingren2hxb at gmail dot com
[Bug gas/33092] Internal error: assertion failure in build_modrm_byte
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/30585] as ignores {disp16} in 16bit mode
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug gas/30585] as ignores {disp16} in 16bit mode
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/27259] ld: Support SHF_LINK_ORDER self-link
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/30551] [RISCV] Improper endian encoding when using floats and doubles with -mbig-endian
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/14798] gas mips target generates badly typed symbols
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/31326] SCFI must handle non QWORD ALU with imm and MOV ops correctly
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/13802] ld testsuite failure: comm-data.exp Common symbol override test; referred common symbol not UNDefined
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/13675] Broken x86 binaries for march < i686 (SIGILL due to multi byte NOP)
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/13616] linker should pad executable sections with nops, not zeros
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/19011] Issues with ld on mingw-w64 and bad defaults
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/4356] windres fails on files with spaces
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/28168] csky overflows disassembly stack buffer
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gold/23535] gold needs to produce two PT_NOTE segments with ELFCLASS64
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/28447] [AIX] .file pseudo-op should accept multiple parameters
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/22085] AIX visibility in .extern, .globl, .weak, .comm not supported
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/22085] AIX visibility in .extern, .globl, .weak, .comm not supported
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/22085] AIX visibility in .extern, .globl, .weak, .comm not supported
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/28981] objdump: objdump: Warning: Unrecognized form: 0x22
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/24676] [RISCV] Redundant R_RISCV_DTPMOD* R_RISCV_DTPREL* resulted from Global Dynamic -> Local Exec relaxation
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/30444] Implementation of COFF/PE format lacks base64 support (Extended COFF Object)
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/30568] --dependency-file includes temporary LTO files
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/27230] ld: Add DWARF v5 sections and .debug_types to ld/scripttempl/DWARF.sc
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/31106] strip --strip-debug breaks relocations
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/30957] aarch64: unnecessary bti veneer
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/31323] [x86] GAS does not error out instruction that exceed 15 bytes
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/19977] [mips] gas writes incorrect addendum for %tprel_hi relocation
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/19977] [mips] gas writes incorrect addendum for %tprel_hi relocation
macro at orcam dot me.uk
[Bug gas/19977] [mips] gas writes incorrect addendum for %tprel_hi relocation
macro at orcam dot me.uk
[Bug ld/11539] ld --gc-sections should work for PE-COFF on MinGW
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/11539] ld --gc-sections should work for PE-COFF on MinGW
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/24322] ld -z shstk sometimes sets IBT property even if -z ibt is not passed
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/30907] ELF segment add extra 2 LOAD segments in aarch64, making binary bigger 128KiB than before
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/31850] aarch64: unnecessary GOT entries and relocations for discarded references
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/26518] [2.35|regression|bisected] DWARF error: could not find variable specification
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/26520] "objdump: DWARF error: could not find variable specification at offset ..." when generating assembly listing of .elf file containing symbols from libstdc++.a
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/26520] "objdump: DWARF error: could not find variable specification at offset ..." when generating assembly listing of .elf file containing symbols from libstdc++.a
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/26520] "objdump: DWARF error: could not find variable specification at offset ..." when generating assembly listing of .elf file containing symbols from libstdc++.a
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/26675] 32bit build of dxvk fails with binutils 2.35.1
oleg.tolmatcev at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/26675] 32bit build of dxvk fails with binutils 2.35.1
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/26675] 32bit build of dxvk fails with binutils 2.35.1
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/27282] ld: Should SHF_GNU_RETAIN/STT_GNU_IFUNC/STB_GNU_UNIQUE work for ELFOSABI_NONE object files?
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/27282] ld: Should SHF_GNU_RETAIN/STT_GNU_IFUNC/STB_GNU_UNIQUE work for ELFOSABI_NONE object files?
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33086] New: objcopy: out-of-memory in bfd_init_section_compress_status
jaehoon.jang at kaist dot ac.kr
[Bug ld/12614] mingw ld omits needed jump stubs in link involving --start/end-group
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/22676] dlltool produces invalid code for 32bit delayload import-lib
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/22676] dlltool produces invalid code for 32bit delayload import-lib
sourceware-bugzilla at jdrake dot com
[Bug binutils/22676] dlltool produces invalid code for 32bit delayload import-lib
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] New: strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33078] strip misbehaves on non-LTO static libraries
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug gprofng/33077] New: hexadecimal representation of instruction is wrong on aarch64
vladimir.mezentsev at oracle dot com
[Bug gprofng/33077] hexadecimal representation of instruction is wrong on aarch64
vladimir.mezentsev at oracle dot com
[Bug binutils/33075] New: Segmentation fault in elf_map_symbols
jaehoon.jang at kaist dot ac.kr
[Bug binutils/33075] objcopy: Segmentation fault in elf_map_symbols
jaehoon.jang at kaist dot ac.kr
[Bug binutils/33075] objcopy: Segmentation fault in elf_map_symbols
jaehoon.jang at kaist dot ac.kr
[Bug binutils/33075] objcopy: Segmentation fault in elf_map_symbols
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33075] objcopy: Segmentation fault in elf_map_symbols
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/24262] bfd-plugins doesn't respect libdir
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/24262] bfd-plugins doesn't respect libdir
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/18482] bfd-plugins directory conflicts in cross-compiler setups
ossman at cendio dot se
[Bug binutils/18482] bfd-plugins directory conflicts in cross-compiler setups
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gprofng/33058] New: [2.45 Regression] gprofng and mttest are unresolved
doko at debian dot org
[Bug gprofng/33058] [2.45 Regression] gprofng and mttest are unresolved
vladimir.mezentsev at oracle dot com
[Bug libsframe/33051] New: ASAN: heap-buffer-overflow ../../src/libsframe/sframe.c:1054 in sframe_get_funcdesc_with_addr_internal
jamborm at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libsframe/33051] ASAN: heap-buffer-overflow ../../src/libsframe/sframe.c:1054 in sframe_get_funcdesc_with_addr_internal
indu.bhagat at oracle dot com
[Bug libsframe/33051] ASAN: heap-buffer-overflow ../../src/libsframe/sframe.c:1054 in sframe_get_funcdesc_with_addr_internal
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33050] New: objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
dragonarthurx at outlook dot com
[Bug binutils/33050] objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
dragonarthurx at outlook dot com
[Bug binutils/33050] objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33050] objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33050] objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33050] objcopy crashes due to heap corruption caused by a negative-size memset in bfd_elf_set_group_contents.
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33049] New: Heap-buffer-overflow in objcopy when using --interleave and --byte options on a crafted binary input
dragonarthurx at outlook dot com
[Bug binutils/33049] Heap-buffer-overflow in objcopy when using --interleave and --byte options on a crafted binary input
dragonarthurx at outlook dot com
[Bug binutils/33049] Heap-buffer-overflow in objcopy when using --interleave and --byte options on a crafted binary input
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33049] Heap-buffer-overflow in objcopy when using --interleave and --byte options on a crafted binary input
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33049] Heap-buffer-overflow in objcopy when using --interleave and --byte options on a crafted binary input
hjl.tools at gmail dot com
[Bug libctf/33047] New: libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libctf/33047] libctf linking generates unexpectedly hidden types when doing cu-mapped links
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug ld/31175] RISCV load immediate relaxation leaves redundant addi
hai at falconv dot org
[Bug ld/31175] RISCV load immediate relaxation leaves redundant addi
hai at falconv dot org
[Bug ld/33043] New: Support R_AARCH64_GOTPCREL32
dianqk at dianqk dot net
[Bug ld/33043] Support R_AARCH64_GOTPCREL32
dianqk at dianqk dot net
[Bug ld/33043] Support R_AARCH64_GOTPCREL32
dianqk at dianqk dot net
[Bug ld/33043] Support R_AARCH64_GOTPCREL32
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug ld/33043] Support R_AARCH64_GOTPCREL32
i at maskray dot me
[Bug libctf/30985] ctf_add_member_encoded of a type on a parent dumps core
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
eliz at gnu dot org
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
eliz at gnu dot org
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug libctf/31863] Warnings about %z format when compiling ctf-open.c with MinGW
nick.alcock at oracle dot com
[Bug binutils/33033] New: objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
rui314 at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33033] objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
rui314 at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33033] objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33033] objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33033] objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
rui314 at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33033] objcopy/objdump/gdb cannot handle >4GiB compressed debug info section
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/33030] New: [Z80] [PATCH] accept leading zeros on dollar local labels when using -sdcc
aargri at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/23460] regression: ar can not create archive containing many (>1024) lto object files
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/23573] "Too many open files" and binutils 2.31.1-1
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug gas/33029] New: Internal error (segfault) in dwarf2_finish with --gdwarf-5
rsworktech at outlook dot com
[Bug gas/33029] Internal error (segfault) in dwarf2_finish with --gdwarf-5
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug gas/33029] Internal error (segfault) in dwarf2_finish with --gdwarf-5
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33022] New: Heap Buffer Overflow in nm with liblto_plugin.so During strncmp
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33022] Heap Buffer Overflow in nm with liblto_plugin.so During strncmp
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33022] Heap Buffer Overflow in nm with liblto_plugin.so During strncmp
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33014] New: Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33014] Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33014] Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33028] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33028] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33028] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33027] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33027] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33027] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33026] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33026] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33026] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33025] New: Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33025] Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33025] Unknown Crash in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Due to Wild Pointer Dereference
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33024] New: Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33024] Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33024] Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33018] New: Segmentation Fault in ld-new due to Unsupported Relocation Type
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33018] Segmentation Fault in ld-new due to Unsupported Relocation Type
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug ld/33018] Segmentation Fault in ld-new due to Unsupported Relocation Type
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33018] Segmentation Fault in ld-new due to Unsupported Relocation Type
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33023] New: Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33023] Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33023] Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33021] New: Heap Buffer Overflow in ld-new's fwrite During EH Frame Header Writing
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33021] Heap Buffer Overflow in ld-new's fwrite During EH Frame Header Writing
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug ld/33021] Heap Buffer Overflow in ld-new's fwrite During EH Frame Header Writing
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33020] New: Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug ld/33020] Segmentation Fault in _bfd_elf_strtab_offset During Object Content Writing
amodra at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33019] New: Segmentation Fault in elf_x86_64_finish_dynamic_symbol During Linking
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug ld/33019] Segmentation Fault in elf_x86_64_finish_dynamic_symbol During Linking
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/33019] Segmentation Fault in elf_x86_64_finish_dynamic_symbol During Linking
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/33019] Segmentation Fault in elf_x86_64_finish_dynamic_symbol During Linking
nickc at redhat dot com
[Bug ld/33019] Segmentation Fault in elf_x86_64_finish_dynamic_symbol During Linking
cvs-commit at gcc dot gnu.org
[Bug binutils/33016] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33016] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33016] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and demangle_type Functions
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33017] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33017] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33017] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33017] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33017] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path and eat Functions
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33015] New: Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33015] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33015] Stack Overflow in c++filt's demangle_path Function
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33013] New: Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33013] Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33013] Segmentation Fault in elfedit's byte_get_little_endian Function
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33012] New: Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33012] Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
[Bug binutils/33012] Memory Leak in objdump During Section and Symbol Table Processing
sam at gentoo dot org
[Bug binutils/33011] New: Heap Buffer Overflow in nm with liblto_plugin.so During strncmp
xdcao.cs at gmail dot com
Earlier messages