Simon Albrecht <[email protected]> writes: > Am 04.09.2015 um 04:09 schrieb David Kastrup: >> Simon Albrecht <[email protected]> writes: >> >>> Hello, >>> >>> consider the following example: >>> %%%%%%%%%%%% >>> \version "2.19.25" >>> >>> \new Voice << { c''^~ c'' } { a'_~ a' } >> >>> >>> \new Voice << { <c''^~> c'' } { <a'_~> a' } >> >>> >>> { <c''^~ a'_~> <c'' a'> } >>> %%%%%%%%%%%% >>> >>> Contrary to (at least my) expectation the first example gives >>> >>> tie-within-chord.ly:6:33 <0>: warning: Two simultaneous tie events, >>> junking this one >>> >>> \new Voice << { c''^~ c'' } { a' >>> >>> _~ a' } >> >>> >>> and applies the first tie to both notes. >>> The other two give correct output, and it would serve consistency and >>> predictability if the first did also. >>> >>> Possibly related: <http://sourceforge.net/p/testlilyissues/issues/2240/>. >> No, even before the infamous issue 2240 ("Don't wrap EventChord around >> rhythmic events by default.") an in-chord tie on an individual note and >> an independent tie event would have behaved in that manner. Before >> issue 2240, the input would have been translated into what is now >> >> \new Voice << { <c''>^~ <c''> } { <a'>_~ <a'> } >> >> >> \new Voice << { <c''^~> <c''> } { <a'_~> <a'> } >> >> >> { <c''^~ a'_~> <c'' a'> } >> >> and the _result_ from typesetting your input is just like before issue 2240. > > <https://sourceforge.net/p/testlilyissues/issues/4597/> > > My ‘possibly related’ statement was only supposed to indicate that > these issues have similar topics and are likely concerned with similar > parts of the code.
Uh, this is _not_ a bug and _not_ an inconsistency. LilyPond differentiates in-chord ties and whole-chord ties (as with most other articulations). Using parallel music does not magically change the in-chord or out-of-chord character of articulations. Multiple whole-chord ties are redundant and flagged. -- David Kastrup _______________________________________________ bug-lilypond mailing list [email protected] https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-lilypond
