Hi Erik,

Thanks for the update!  Looks good, but one minor comment:

SignJars.gmk
============
78:100:106:111-116 > 80 chars per line.

Brad





On 11/4/2013 2:19 AM, Erik Joelsson wrote:
New webrev posted: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~erikj/8027698/webrev.jdk.02/

Addressed all comments below. I must have missed the save button before
generating the webrev when adding ucrypto.jar, but it's there now at least.

/Erik

On 2013-11-02 01:35, Bradford Wetmore wrote:


On 11/1/2013 3:34 AM, Erik Joelsson wrote:
Please review this simple fix, adding sunmscapi.jar and ucrypto.jar to
the list of jars to be signed by the sign-jars target. Since these jars
are platform dependent, they aren't always present.

Bug: https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8027698
Webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~erikj/8027698/webrev.jdk.01/

/Erik

makefiles/SignJars.gmk
======================

Overall:  Some of the existing/new lines are greater than the standard
80 chars.

2:  Some people update the Copyright date instead of waiting for RE to
do it.  Feel free if you're one of those.

48 & 108:  The RE process for signing jars for JDK 7/8 is completely
different than what was originally written/described for JDK 7.  There
is an additional separate script that RE uses to include the
source_tips into the jar files, and then do the actual signing.
SignJars.gmk is here primarily for developer support.

47:  Suggest changing to:

# SPECIAL NOTE TO JCE/JDK developers: The source files must eventually
# be built, signed, and then the resulting jar files MUST BE CHECKED
# INTO THE CLOSED PART OF THE WORKSPACE*. This separate step *MUST NOT
# BE FORGOTTEN*, otherwise a bug fixed in the source code will not be
# reflected in the shipped binaries.
#
# Please consult with Release Engineering, which is responsible for
# creating the final JCE builds suitable for checkin.
#

94:  I don't see ucrypto.jar listed here.

108:  Can you please update the code here to output:

    The jar files built by the 'sign-jars' target are developer
    builds only and *MUST NOT* be checked into the closed workspace.

    Please consult with Release Engineering: they will generate
    the proper binaries for the closed workspace.

    @$(PRINTF) $(README-MAKEFILE_WARNING)

Since this bug is a subtask of JDK-8027266, I'll add a few more
comments to that bug.  I'm guessing you'll probably want to address
separately.

Thanks, Erik!

Brad

Reply via email to