Hi Mike,

A few minor comments, overall looks good.

On 3/26/2014 2:11 PM, Mike Duigou wrote:
Hello all;

I introduced bug in JDK-8030681 which prevents non-clone commands from 
receiving parameters.

I also slightly cleaned up checking for what is an acceptable root repo as I 
had encountered this in a problem with a local clone and reverted prior change 
which made the script a bash script.

bug:    https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8038435

webrev: http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~mduigou/JDK-8038435/0/webrev/

116 if [ "${command}" = "clone" -o "${command}" = "fclone" ] ; then
221         if [ "${command}" = "clone" -o "${command}" = "fclone" ] ; then

Perhaps out of scope of this fix, but shouldn't we add -o "${command}" = 
"tclone"?
The "fclone" & "tclone" are both cosmetic, neither extensions are used.
Can't remove "fclone" without potentionally breaking scripts.

  127   pull_default_tail=`echo ${pull_default} | sed -e 
's@^.*://[^/]*/\(.*\)@\1@'`
  128   if [ "x${pull_default}" = "x${pull_default_tail}" ] ; then
  129       echo "ERROR: Need initial clone from non-local source" > 
${status_output}
  130       exit 1
  131   fi

The above code looks right for what you want to do, but is it necessary to restrict hgforest.sh to only operate vs non-local?

Seems one should still be able to have their own forest, and clone from that forest locally.

  238           echo "cd ${i} && hg${global_opts} ${command} ${command_args}" > 
${status_output}
  239           cd ${i} && (PYTHONUNBUFFERED=true hg${global_opts} ${command} ${command_args}; echo 
"$?" > ${tmp}/${repopidfile}.pid.rc ) 2>&1 &

Add "PYTHONUNBUFFERED=true" to the echo line.

        Thanks
                Dave


Reply via email to