Looks good.
/Erik
On 2017-12-04 12:40, Magnus Ihse Bursie wrote:
On 2017-12-04 19:17, mandy chung wrote:
On 12/4/17 9:33 AM, Erik Joelsson wrote:
Hello Magnus,
The <module>-copy targets are currently only being generated for
modules that have make/copy/Copy-<module>.gmk makefiles present. By
removing make/copy/Copy-jdk.accessibility.gmk and
make/copy/Copy-jdk.jdwp.agent.gmk, those targets are no longer
created so the logic in CopyCommon will not be executed.
This can be solved in two ways. Either generate <module>-copy rules
for all modules or leave the files there with just include
CopyCommon.gmk as the only contents. I would recommend the latter
for now. Most modules do not need to copy anything.
Is it possible to generate <module>-copy rules for module where
src/<module>/{share, $OS}/include directory or
make/copy/Copy-<module>.gmk is present?
Technically, it's of course possible. But it does not fit very well
with the current DeclareRecipesForPhase. I agree with Erik, that for
now the reasonable approach is to have files that only include
CopyCommon. We can consider for future updates if it's worth
generalizing this.
Updated webrev that restores the removed Copy-$MODULE.gmk files:
http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ihse/JDK-8190484-move-hotspot-exported-includes/webrev.02
Another minor note, when ordering include directories, I usually put
the most specific dir first, so that any platform specific header
file with the same name would override a more general one. We don't
have that situation in this case, but I still think it's good practice.
Regarding where to push this. IMO, if it depends on a change
currently in hs, push it to hs. If it ends up in JDK 10 or 11
doesn't really matter that much.
I would love this in JDK 10 if time permits and I am happy to see
Coleen retarget it to 10. This is a really nice clean up that shows
the benefit from JEP 201 w.r.t. exported native header files. But
this is not a must for JDK 10 and if it can't make 10, it's okay for 11.
Ok. I'll try to get it into jdk 10. Will push this to jdk/jdk as soon
as the needed fixes are integrated from jdk/hs.
/Magnus
Mandy
/Erik
On 2017-12-04 03:06, Magnus Ihse Bursie wrote:
JDK-8190484 was created as a follow-up bug to the unification of
the duplicated jvm.h, jvm_md.h and jmm.h, to determine the proper
location of these files. This has now been decided to be
hotspot/share/include and hotspot/os/$OS/include, respectively.
This patch moves the relevant files there, but since this also
frees up the src/$MODULE/native/include directories for the
original purpose, it also unifies and simplifies the build logic
for these directories, so that common code is executed for all
modules to just copy any exported header files from these
directories, should they exist.
I'm intending to push this to jdk-hs.
Bug: https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8190484
WebRev:
http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ihse/JDK-8190484-move-hotspot-exported-includes/webrev.01
/Magnus
