Hi Magus,
I haven't looked at the changes yet, other to see that there are many
files touched, but after reading below (and only partly understanding
since I don't know this area well), I was wondering if this issue
wouldn't be better served with multiple passes made to fix the warnings.
Start with a straight forward one where you are maybe only making one or
two types of changes, but that affect a large number of files and don't
cascade into other more complicated changes. This will get a lot of the
noise out of the way, and then we can focus on some of the harder issues
you bring up below.
As for testing, I think the following list will capture all of them, but
can't say for sure:
open/test/hotspot/jtreg/serviceability/sa
open/test/hotspot/jtreg/resourcehogs/serviceability/sa
open/test/jdk/sun/tools/jhsdb
open/test/jdk/sun/tools/jstack
open/test/jdk/sun/tools/jmap
open/test/hotspot/jtreg/gc/metaspace/CompressedClassSpaceSizeInJmapHeap.java
open/test/hotspot/jtreg/compiler/ciReplay/TestSAClient.java
open/test/hotspot/jtreg/compiler/ciReplay/TestSAServer.java
Chris
On 3/25/20 12:29 PM, Magnus Ihse Bursie wrote:
With the recent fixes in JDK-8241310, JDK-8237746 and JDK-8241073, and
the upcoming fixes to remove the deprecated nashorn and jdk.rmi, the
JDK build is very close to producing no warnings when compiling the
Java classes.
The one remaining sinner is jdk.hotspot.agent. Most of the warnings
here are turned off, but unchecked and deprecation cannot be
completely silenced.
Since the poor agent does not seem to receive much love nowadays, I
took it upon myself to fix these warnings, so we can finally get a
quiet build.
I started to address the unchecked warnings. Unfortunately, this was a
much bigger task than I anticipated. I had to generify most of the
module. On the plus side, the code is so much better now. And most of
the changes were trivial, just tedious.
There are a few places were I'm not entirely happy with the current
solution, and that at least merits some discussion.
I have resorted to @SuppressWarnings in four classes: ciMethodData,
MethodData, TableModelComparator and VirtualBaseConstructor. All of
them has in common that they are doing slightly fishy things with
classes in collections. I'm not entirely sure they are bug-free, but
this patch leaves the behavior untouched. I did some efforts to sort
out the logic, but it turned out to be too hairy for me to fix, and it
will probably require more substantial changes to the workings of the
code.
To make the code valid, I have moved ConstMethod to extend Metadata
instead of VMObject. My understanding is that this is benign (and
likely intended), but I really need for someone who knows the code to
confirm this. I have also added a FIXME to signal this. I'll remove
the FIXME as soon as I get confirmation that this is OK.
(The reason for this is the following piece of code from
Metadata.java: metadataConstructor.addMapping("ConstMethod",
ConstMethod.class))
In ObjectListPanel, there is some code that screams "dead" with this
change. I added a FIXME to point this out:
for (Iterator<Oop> iter = elements.iterator(); iter.hasNext(); ) {
if (iter.next() instanceof Array) {
// FIXME: Does not seem possible to happen
hasArrays = true;
return;
}
It seems that if you start pulling this thread, even more dead code
will unravel, so I'm not so eager to touch this in the current patch.
But I can remove the FIXME if you want.
My first iteration of this patch tried to generify the IntervalTree
and related class hierarchy. However, this turned out to be impossible
due to some weird usage in AnnotatedMemoryPanel, where there seemed to
be confusion as to whether the tree stored Annotations or Addresses.
I'm not entirely convinced the code is correct, it certainly looked
and smelled very fishy. However, I reverted these changes since I
could not get them to work due to this, and it was not needed for the
goal of just getting rid of the warning.
Finally, I have done no testing apart from verifying that it builds.
Please advice on suitable tests to run.
Bug: https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8241618
WebRev:
http://cr.openjdk.java.net/~ihse/JDK-8241618-fix-unchecked-warnings-for-agent/webrev.01
/Magnus