Hi Evan and Ethan.
Thanks for your inputs.
On 05/20/09 14:41, Evan Layton wrote:
> I think that providing the information that there was a mis-match
> falls under the XML parsing work. It needs to find the mis-match
> collect the relevant information about that mis-match and report that
> back to the caller. Once that's done then yes it would be up to the AI
> client to deal with perhaps logging the error or additional
> information but that information should come from the parser.
This makes sense to me, that the parser return what errors it finds so
that the caller (e.g. AI client) can gracefully and "usefully" handle
the failure (generate a useful error message, etc).
Thanks,
Jack
>
> -evan
>
> Ethan Quach wrote:
>>
>>
>> Evan Layton wrote:
>>> With respect to the schema and manifest version work I think we
>>> would also want a requirement that not only does the installer
>>> detect this mis-match but logs a message and passes an error back to
>>> the rest of the installer. We want to make sure that when these
>>> mis-matches are found that the user is informed in a way that they
>>> know what actions they may need to take to either correct the
>>> problem or make sure they are getting defined and expected behavior
>>> from the install.
>>
>> How is that a requirement for XML parsing team? That seems like its
>> a requirement to the AI client redesign team.
>>
>> -ethan
>>
>>>
>>> just my $0.02... ;-)
>>>
>>> -evan
>>>
>>> Jack Schwartz wrote:
>>>> Hi AI rework project teams,
>>>>
>>>> Please send your XML parsing requirements to the XML Parsing Rework
>>>> Team so that we can give you what you need. (Or, please let us
>>>> know that your team's requirements are already being handled, if
>>>> that is the case.) Please get the list to us as soon as you can,
>>>> by Thursday COB latest.
>>>>
>>>> For context, please have a look at the problem statements we are
>>>> solving, and have a look at the strawman proposal for an idea of
>>>> where we are going. The strawman proposal will be revised
>>>> according to your needs. Both can be found at:
>>>>
>>>> http://opensolaris.org/os/project/caiman/XML_Parsing/
>>>>
>>>> Thanks,
>>>> Jack
>>>
>
