Hi William,

On Thu, 9 Apr 2009, William Schumann wrote:

> There are two problems addressed by this bug.
>
> 1) After initial AI installation, the swap slice is regarded as user data in 
> subsequent AI installations instead of scratch
> 2) The swap slice space allocation in TI is not done with any awareness of AI 
> customization
>
> The fix involving making AI aware of 1 and for AI to perform 2 instead of 
> leaving everything to TI, which allocates the swap space for GUI.

So, from a high level, is it fair to say that the policy 
with respect to preserving slices by default isn't being
changed? And, the change you're making here is to create
a swap slice if either s1 doesn't exist or s1 exists with
a V_SWAP tag. Correct?

Also now that 7718 has been reversed in the source code
only machines with less than 700MB memory will see this
problem on every other AI install after the *first* install.

Given this, the question in my mind is whether it is worth
making complicated changes like these this late in the
release for a relatively small set of machine. Or, to think
through the problem we're solving more carefully and defer
it to the next release.

Do others have an opinion on this?

Alok

Reply via email to