I haven't noticed any significant problems when lots of Models are
loaded like that by Cake as long as they are not being used. (I have
over 50 models and probably 1/4 - 1/2 of them are involved in many
requests)

Of-course it would be better if they were never loaded into RAM. When
I use php-caching (eAccelerator) on my live-server things are fast
enough and the overhead is reduced.

I am also looking forward to what Cake will be capable of without PHP4
holding it back.

/Martin


On Aug 10, 5:09 pm, "euromark (munich)" <[email protected]>
wrote:
> thanks for your reply
>
> i cant see though, what "containable" has to do with it
> with containable (what i use globally through app_model by default)
> you can narrow down the result
> but it is not the result i am worrying about
>
> those classes above (and therefore as many objects?) are included
> anyway
> although there is no need for them whatsoever
>
> if i wouldnt use containable and set recursive on > 0 i would get all
> those
> user related infos as well. but then i would not bother about those
> included classes
>
> in my case they are no calls to these models - and they are not used
> in any query
> but i guess that is the problem here: cake prepares everything as if
> you want to
> containable or recursive can avoid the query, but they can't avoid
> that these files get included
> am i right?
>
> the problem is: some day there are almost 30 classes included which
> would not be neccessary
> this could make up as much as all those "actually needed" classes
> together - and therefore slows everything down.
>
> i guess your array / objects reason makes sense...
> maybe with pure PHP5 in 1.3 there will be some new approaches
> possible :)
>
> On 10 Aug., 15:43, Martin Westin <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>
>
> > I think you may be on a different level to that trac note.
>
> > You would have to confirm the following but I believe this is
> > generally correct:
> > Cake does lazy loading of the classes... classes never referenced
> > during a request will not be included, loaded and instantiated.
> > Cake does no lazy loading of a Model's sql data, which is what would
> > be slowing things down as your database starts to fill up.
>
> > PHP4 can partly be blamed, I guess. Cake chooses to return all Model
> > data as arrays... arrays can't magically load themselves on request as
> > objects can. The benefit of arrays (in PHP) is their simplicity and
> > wide support for array operations.
>
> > Have you put Cake's Containable behaviour to use on your Models?
> > If you have, then should be fine.
>
> > On Aug 10, 12:28 pm, "euromark (munich)" <[email protected]>
> > wrote:
>
> > > hey guys
> > > i always though cake has (like yii) some build in lazy loading feature
> > > for the models not needed (although linked in the relation arrays (HM,
> > > HABTM etc)
> > > as stated here:https://trac.cakephp.org/wiki/notes/1.1.x.x
>
> > > after wondering why my page got slower and slower on some views that
> > > didnt need most of the > 20 relations for the user model, i did some
> > > research
>
> > > i found out that almost all models are still included and (probably)
> > > loaded/instantiated
> > > do i need to addiotionally patch the loading behaviour if i want to
> > > have the "real" lazy loading? meaning that the models are loaded only
> > > if really needed for data retrieval or functionatily? (and is this due
> > > to the fact that it still has to support php4?)
>
> > > as you can see below, most of the models are not even used once in the
> > > queries or the functions called from controller/model
>
> > > thx :)
>
> > > "queries" (debug 0! no describes etc) log file:
>
> > > SELECT `Poll`.`id`, `Poll`.`cat_id`, `Poll`.`user_id`, `Poll`.`name`,
> > > `Poll`.`descr`, `Poll`.`details_descr`, `Poll`.`layout`,
> > > `Poll`.`active`, `Poll`.`creator_info`, `Poll`.`allow_edit`,
> > > `Poll`.`allow_add`, `Poll`.`allow_access`, `Poll`.`allow_vote`,
> > > `Poll`.`allow_comments`, `Poll`.`multiple`, `Poll`.`result_details`,
> > > `Poll`.`result_show`, `Poll`.`result_type`, `Poll`.`start_date`,
> > > `Poll`.`end_date`, `Poll`.`notify`, `Poll`.`modified` FROM `tel_polls`
> > > AS `Poll` WHERE `Poll`.`user_id` = '1' ORDER BY `Poll`.`modified` DESC
> > > LIMIT 20                3       3       1
> > > SELECT `PollOption`.`id`, `PollOption`.`active`,
> > > `PollOption`.`poll_id` FROM `tel_poll_options` AS `PollOption` WHERE
> > > `PollOption`.`poll_id` IN ('49c1c4c3-48a4-4359-8acf-0b1cdb7b895a',
> > > '49dad9cd-597c-45f1-aca3-09a8db7b895a',
> > > '49dab2c5-24bc-46c8-8d28-09a8db7b895a')         5       5       1
> > > SELECT `PollVote`.`id`, `PollVote`.`poll_id` FROM `tel_poll_votes` AS
> > > `PollVote` WHERE `PollVote`.`poll_id` IN
> > > ('49c1c4c3-48a4-4359-8acf-0b1cdb7b895a', '49dad9cd-597c-45f1-
> > > aca3-09a8db7b895a', '49dab2c5-24bc-46c8-8d28-09a8db7b895a')             3 
> > >       3       1
> > > SELECT `Document`.`id`, `Document`.`foreign_id` FROM `tel_documents`
> > > AS `Document` WHERE `Document`.`type` = 'polls' AND
> > > `Document`.`foreign_id` IN ('49c1c4c3-48a4-4359-8acf-0b1cdb7b895a',
> > > '49dad9cd-597c-45f1-aca3-09a8db7b895a',
> > > '49dab2c5-24bc-46c8-8d28-09a8db7b895a')         3       3       1
> > > SELECT `Comment`.`id`, `Comment`.`foreign_id` FROM `tel_comments` AS
> > > `Comment` WHERE `Comment`.`type` = 'polls' AND `Comment`.`foreign_id`
> > > IN ('49c1c4c3-48a4-4359-8acf-0b1cdb7b895a', '49dad9cd-597c-45f1-
> > > aca3-09a8db7b895a', '49dab2c5-24bc-46c8-8d28-09a8db7b895a')             0 
> > >       0       1
> > > SELECT `LogVisitor`.`id`, `LogVisitor`.`foreign_id` FROM
> > > `tel_log_visitors` AS `LogVisitor` WHERE `LogVisitor`.`type` = 'polls'
> > > AND `LogVisitor`.`foreign_id` IN
> > > ('49c1c4c3-48a4-4359-8acf-0b1cdb7b895a', '49dad9cd-597c-45f1-
> > > aca3-09a8db7b895a', '49dab2c5-24bc-46c8-8d28-09a8db7b895a')             1 
> > >       1       1
> > > SELECT `Role`.`id`, `Role`.`name` FROM `tel_roles` AS `Role` WHERE 1 =
> > > 1 ORDER BY `Role`.`parent_id` DESC
>
> > > "loading" log file:
>
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\router.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\controller\component.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\overloadable.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\view\helper.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\class_registry.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\view\view.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\controller\controller.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \dispatcher.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \app_controller.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\polls_controller.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\components\session.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\components\common.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\controller\components\request_handler.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\components\auth.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\components\auth_ext.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \controllers\components\jquery.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\validation.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\model\behavior.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\model\connection_manager.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\model\model.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \app_model.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\poll.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\model\datasources\dbo\dbo_mysql.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\user.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\role.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\cake
> > > \libs\model\behaviors\containable.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\address.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\address_type.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\location.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\country_province.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\country.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\behaviors\multiple_display_fields.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\behaviors\geocoder.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\category.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\date.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\date_type.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\email_address.php
> > > 2009-08-10 12:15:25 Load_1249899325: F:\PHP\xampp\htdocs\tel\p\tel
> > > \models\jabber.php
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"CakePHP" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/cake-php?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to