man, 18.02.2008 kl. 11.50 +0100, skrev Massimo Cetra: > Mikael Aleksander Bjerkeland wrote: > > man, 18.02.2008 kl. 09.26 +0100, skrev CtRiX: > > > >> Mikael Aleksander Bjerkeland wrote: > >> > >>> I tried nat=never. No difference. The logs from this call can be found > >>> here: http://openpbx.pastebin.ca/908268 > >>> > >>> I will try to do some regresssion testing to find out where it broke. > >>> > >>> > >> Useless logs. > >> > >> Please: > >> sip debug, > >> set verbose 9 > >> set debug 9 > >> rtp debug > >> > >> and use the full log, not the console. > >> > > Log: http://openpbx.pastebin.ca/908318 > > > There is some code like this: > > if ( option_debug > 5 ) > opbx_log(LOG_DEBUG,"Nat is not needed (condition 1)\n"); > > I cannot find this code in chan_sip.c. This is 1.2 btw, not SVN. I should have mentioned it earlier.
> that should match the nat condition logic and show which one is actually > choosen. > I don't see any evidence of those logs so 2 causes here: > 1) old version of chan_sip or > 2) debug is not >5 Debug is >5, but the section in chan_sip you are referring to is not in 1.2 SVN 4015. It is in 4500 which I am using now. > > I need to see how the code manages the conditions and here i don't see it. > > More: what's your localnets options in sip.conf ? externip = 78.24.88.22 localnet=192.168.0.0/255.255.0.0; All RFC 1918 addresses are local networks localnet=10.0.0.0/255.0.0.0 ; Also RFC1918 nat=route I don't know why I have that IP in the SDP lines. I tried both nat=never and nat=no, also nat=yes. The content of the logs may change slightly, but the behaviour is the same. The logs can be found here: http://openpbx.pastebin.ca/index.php This time I used nat=no on both server1 and server2. > > CW is using what i believe is the external IP (78.24.88.22) so most > probably you have a configuration problem. This is the correct external IP. > > How can you use nat=never and have such an IP in the SDP lines ? I have no clue. Is there a difference in the logs now? > > Max > > _______________________________________________ Callweaver-users mailing list [email protected] http://lists.callweaver.org/mailman/listinfo/callweaver-users
