James,
Yeah, we could (and probably should) do that, but -- for Vasil's use
case -- what features would you expect on top of what you can do now
using implementation.java and implementation.spring?
Gert
James Strachan wrote:
Agreed - I guess someone could hack up a Tuscany plugin for Camel?
2008/5/22 Gert Vanthienen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
Vasil,
I'm not an SCA expert at all, but...
If you want to use Camel inside an SCA component, I think you should be able
to Tuscany's implementation.java or implementation.spring to do this. If
you hide the interaction with the other components behind a Java interface
as usual, it shouldn't matter if implementation is Camel or any other Java
code. You can choose to specify the Camel's routes in a java class or a
Spring configuration file and use that inside your SCA component. Camel
itself is just a JAR file you have to include in your (not sure about the
terminology either) SCA composite. It shouldn't be too hard to have
synchronous execution in Camel -- just avoid the typical asynchronous
concepts as seda: endpoints and you should be fine there.
Suppose we would build a more specific implementation.camel for Apache
Camel, what additional features would you expect from that implementation?
Gert
Vasil wrote:
Hi Willem,
I was thinking for using the route and pattern description power of Camel
inside an SCA component for a more declarative description of integration
scenario between services to which this component refers. I could have
used
BPEL or BPMN for example but this is rather complex and
procedural-oriented,
while I need mainly transformation capabilities with simple conditions
(content-based router), split, agregate, filter, transform (XQuery for
example), etc. in more data-oriented scenario.
In this case the different connectivities (components) that Camel provides
will not be needed as SCA cares for this and also anly synchronous working
of the Camel engine will be used.
Do you think this is feasible usage of Camel?
Bye, Vasil
willem.jiang wrote:
Hi Vasil,
AFAIK , we do not have any plan to integrate Camel with SCA. But you
could share you ideas with us in the mail list :)
Willem
Vasil wrote:
Hi,
Is there any integration between Camel and SCA planned. If yes, can you
share some more information.
Bye, Vasil
