A.M. Kuchling wrote:
On Fri, Dec 10, 2004 at 12:51:01PM -0600, Ian Bicking wrote:

* Add a field for source download; maybe make it a dictionary, so you can give several links for different sources (e.g., source tarball/zip, rpm, windows installer, debian package, etc).


An up-and-coming standard for info about packages is an RDF vocabulary
called DOAP: http://usefulinc.com/doap .  IMHO we should think about
harmonizing the Distutils-supported metadata with DOAP.  I've
submitted a crude patch to PyPI that generates DOAP data for projects.

Things in DOAP not in Distutils/PyPI:

CVS/SVN/BK repository (+ anonymous root, module name)
Mailing lists
Wiki URL
Bug database
Screenshot URL
Date project was created
Releases

Like multiple released branches, or historical releases?

Versions are a revision number (1.2.3, 1.0a1, etc.) plus name and date.
Multiple language literals (e.g. give both an English and a
French description).


However, just adding keywords to setup.core() for all these things may
not be a good idea -- if DOAP adds new features, we need to add
support for them. Perhaps there should be some third-party way of
constructing a DOAP file, after which you'd leave the metadata out of
the setup.core() invocation.

I'd like this anyway -- it feels distracting that setup.py contains both metadata for PyPI, and control data for distutils. There's some intersection, but most of the data really belongs to one or the other.


I'm heavily drawn to using source to represent data, but despite that I think a static file would be appropriate for most of these descriptions. Or maybe a feature to setup() that reads metadata from a static file (so you could generate the data in other ways if you really wanted, e.g., an analogous .ini file).

OTOH, requiring an RDF parser to deal with the metadata is also nasty;
parsers are pretty large, and adding one to the core might be a
struggle.

Is an RDF parser very complicated? It's mostly just XML with namespaces isn't it? Do the standard library's XML parsers handle namespaces well?


--
Ian Bicking  /  [EMAIL PROTECTED]  /  http://blog.ianbicking.org
_______________________________________________
Catalog-sig mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/catalog-sig

Reply via email to