On Mon, 15 Aug 2005 09:06 am, Phillip J. Eby wrote:
> After thinking over the last week's distutils-sig discussion about
> security, signatures, etc., I think I have a plan for handling basic file
> integrity checking and (non-cryptographic) trust management for
> EasyInstall.

I'm not on the distutils-sig any more (not sure why - I thought I was and 
there just wasn't any discussion going on ;) so I've missed that discussion.


> The first part of the plan is to add md5 digest checking to
> EasyInstall.  Because one of EasyInstall's design goals is to make it easy
> for anybody to publish links to packages, we need to be able to include the
> md5 signature in a package's URL.  I'm thinking we could achieve this via
> an '#md5=...' fragment identifier.  For example, a setuptools source
> archive URL might be:
>
> http://www.python.org/packages/source/s/setuptools/setuptools-0.5a13.zip#md
>5=91f31a9058330174640a867cf5d4de57

Any idea what various "normal" browsers do when they encounter something like 
this?


> The advantage of this approach is that it allows anyone to assert what the
> md5 of the targeted file is, and it can be asserted in any web page, just
> by pointing an HREF at the file.  EasyInstall could detect the '#md5='
> marker, and then use this to verify the file during download.
>
> The disadvantage, of course, is that PyPI doesn't currently support this;

As with all things that "PyPI doesn't currently support" I'm happy to add 
features, and even happier for others to add features :)


> So, this is not a complete security solution, as it doesn't deal with
> end-to-end file integrity, and could easily be subverted by taking over a
> site somewhere in the middle (e.g. python.org).  But until we have more of
> the cryptographic infrastructure in place, I think this plan could provide
> us with a good starting point.  Comments, anyone?

I presume the distutils discussion included the signing of packages that PyPI 
supports?


     Richard

Attachment: pgp5nFH4d68UH.pgp
Description: PGP signature

_______________________________________________
Catalog-sig mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/catalog-sig

Reply via email to