"situational awareness" - 'awareness of the situation', knowledge and
awareness of the environment.

For the scope of the lab, beyond the task itself, you should be aware of
what section you are in and what you are asked to do.

Since this task is specifically in the BGP section, the conclusion that
should be drawn is that this is referring specifically to BGP, not OSPF to
OSPF information.  Asking the proctor for clarification would be
recommended, if you are unsure is always recommended.

Had this section been under OSPF, then possibly filtering between the two
routers would be the direction to take.

Marvin Greenlee, CCIE #12237 (R&S, SP, Sec)
Senior Technical Instructor - IPexpert, Inc.
Telephone: +1.810.326.1444
Fax: +1.810.454.0130
Mailto: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Progress or excuses, which one are you making?
 


-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Suresh Mishra
Sent: Thursday, July 03, 2008 3:56 PM
To: OSL CCIE Routing and Switching Lab Exam
Subject: [OSL | CCIE_RS] VOL2-LAB9-task-4.2

Hell all,

In this section R2 is redistributing OSPF into  BGP and is advertising
it to R6. At the same time, R2 and R6 are ospf neighbors and are
advertising ospf routes to each other.  Now there is a question in
this section that reads as follows.

"R6 should not receive any routes from R2 that are from the ospf
domain. No network statements are allowed.".

After reading this question, I used "ip ospf database" filter command
and filtered all the LSA's that were send to R6 from R2 as I was not
allowed to use network statement that would allow me to disable OSPF
on the interface.

However, P.G uses a solution where it filtered OSPF routes that were
redistributed into BGP. I think this question wants us to not have the
ospf routes propagated to the OSPF neighbors  via BGP routes.

I think this question needs one simple modification. Instead of saying
"any ospf routes" that includes OSPF routes only (as per the English
language understanding), Instead it should say BGP routes. That means
it should read something like this.

"R6 should not receive any BGP routes from R2 that are from the ospf
domain. No network statements are allowed"


I know there will always be a language issue with CCIE. But I think
making something difficult by using a language twist makes it more
confusing than technically challenging.



Thanks
Suresh

Reply via email to