***  For details on how to be removed from this list visit the  ***
***          CCP4 home page http://www.ccp4.ac.uk         ***


On Fri, Nov 04, 2005 at 07:49:34AM -0600, Mischa Machius wrote:
> 
> The recent discussion about molecular biology has prompted me to try  
> again to suggest moving the bulletin board to a modern, web-based  
> format. I have suggested this in the past with mixed results. Most  
> "hip" bulletin boards (poetry, music, cars, etc.) are organized that  
> way; the CCP4BB is behind the time.
> 

hip != modern, nor does it imply usability/simplicity.

> The most often voiced argument against this idea, and in favor of an  
> email-based system, was that an email-based system keeps one on their  
> toes. This is because one choses to monitor one's email account. If  
> one would choose to monitor a web browser window, one would have the  
> same benefits. In addition, one could always have any message posted  
> to the board automatically forwarded to one's email account.
> 

I don't get it - if a mailing list is causing too much traffic, why
not just have it carried by gmane, then the folks that don't want the
email use a newsreader or the gmane web interface (which is really
cool, IMHO) instead?  This works great for the LKML, which spits out
something like 250 messages a day.

> The benefits of a modern system are numerous. It is easy to set up  
> different sections, so that one would not have to sign up for 15  
> different bulletin boards (O, CNS, CCP4, etc., etc.). We would thus  
> have a unified platform. Email accounts won't get clogged. Such a  
> board would be accessible from any access point to the Internet,  
> whereas email may not always be that easy to get to. There are also  
> powerful communication tools, like personal messaging and chat rooms  
> that make interacting a lot more straightforward compared to email.
> 

If the mailing list is hard to configure/sign up for/use, has anyone
administering the CCP4BB considered mailman
(http://www.gnu.org/software/mailman/)?  It provides a fantastic web
interface to handle everything related to configuration and
subscriptions.

> To pre-empt the argument presented by some people last time I  
> mentioned this, that it would be too difficult to get used to a new  
> system, I would say, it is much more difficult to get used to a new  
> piece of software, or even a new version of it. We are all  
> intelligent people (or so one would assume), able to adjust  
> instantaneously to new scientific results. We would certainly be able  
> to adjust to a new way of clicking buttons.
> 

Yes, but I don't want to click a button.  A GUI should in no way be
required.  I want to just hit ctrl-D in mutt (it sucks less!) and move
on to the next thread.  ;)

-Tim

-- 
---------------------------------------------------------

        Tim Fenn
        [EMAIL PROTECTED]
        Stanford University, School of Medicine
        James H. Clark Center
        318 Campus Drive, Room E300
        Stanford, CA  94305-5432
        Phone:  (650) 736-1714
        FAX:  (650) 736-1961

---------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to