Dear bulletin board members,

A referee came back with a question about the accuracy of refined 
group-occupancies. In the manuscript we describe 3 crystal structures with 
resolutions between 2.1 and 2.4 Å. In all three cases, the inhibitor has been 
fitted in two alternative conformations and the group occupancy of each 
conformation has been refined and the relative occupancies vary depending on 
the inhibitor.

The accuracy will depend on the amount of overlap between the inhibitor 
densities and the amount of unique density belonging only to one conformation 
and the amount of additional disorder of the inhibitors, since most of the 
interactions are non-specific hydrophobic interactions. Also partially occupied 
solvent molecules could lead to errors in the refined occupancies. My gut 
feeling is that the error will be somewhere between 20 and 30% or even higher, 
but I would be very happy if someone could come with a more scientific way, 
however crude, to get an estimate of this error.

Best regards,
Herman

Reply via email to