According to chkudf tool (present on linux udf 0.9.0), it is possible
that mkisofs is not generating compliant volumes. Please check this
output:
--Determining device/media parameters.
ioctl error 1.
Guessing revealed 2048 byte sector size.
Last Sector = 131285 (0x200d5) and is not accurate
Adjusted last sector to 131283.
--Verifying the Volume Recognition Sequence.
VRS 0 (sector 16): ISO 9660 Primary Volume Descriptor
VRS 1 (sector 17): ISO 9660 Volume Descriptor Set Terminator
VRS 2 (sector 18): 2 ISO 9660 descriptors found.
VRS 2 : Beginning Extended Area descriptor found.
VRS 3 (sector 19): NSR02 descriptor found.
VRS 4 (sector 20): VRS sequence was terminated.
--Verifying the Anchor Volume Descriptor Pointers.
Checking 256: AVDP present.
Checking 512: No AVDP.
Checking 131283 (n - 0): AVDP present.
Checking 131133 (n - 150): No AVDP.
Checking 131027 (n - 256): No AVDP.
Checking 130877 (n - 406): No AVDP.
Found 2 Anchor Volume Descriptor Pointers.
Main Volume Descriptor Sequence is at 32, 32768 bytes long.
Reserve Volume Descriptor Sequence is at 48, 32768 bytes long.
--Verifying Volume Descriptor Sequences.
--Reading the Main Volume Descriptor Sequence.
Main VDS (00000020): Found first PVD.
Main VDS (00000021): Found first IUVD.
Main VDS (00000022): Found first PD.
Main VDS (00000023): Found first LVD.
Main VDS (00000024): Found first USD.
Main VDS (00000025): terminated by a Terminating Descriptor.
--Reading the Reserve Volume Descriptor Sequence.
Reserve VDS (00000030): Found first PVD.
Reserve VDS (00000031): Found first IUVD.
Reserve VDS (00000032): Found first PD.
Reserve VDS (00000033): Found first LVD.
Reserve VDS (00000034): Found first USD.
Reserve VDS (00000035): terminated by a Terminating Descriptor.
--Primary Volume Descriptor Information:
(M) Volume Identifier: 'dvd_pedrinho'
(M) Volume Set ID: '55D5E6BD000053F5'
**(R) Volume Set ID: '55D5E6BD0000545A'
(M) Recording Time: 2015/08/20 11:39:57.000000 (Local), -180 min. from CUT
(M) Primary Volume Descriptor number is 0.
**(M) Max. Interchange level is 2.
(M) App. ID: '' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
(M) Impl. ID: '*mkisofs' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
--Unallocated Volume Space Descriptor Information:
(M) Number of Allocation Descriptors: 0
--Logical Volume Descriptor Information:
(M) Logical Volume ID: 'dvd_pedrinho'
(M) Impl. ID: '*mkisofs' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
(M) File Set Descriptor location is 4096 bytes @ 0:0
(M) There is 1 partition map entry.
(M) Partition map entry 0 is type 1 (real) and references partition 0.
(M) Integrity Sequence is 4096 bytes at 64.
Verifying the Logical Volume Integrity Descriptor Sequence.
LVID at 00000040: recorded at 2015/08/20 11:39:57.000000 (Local),
-180 min. from CUT
[Close]
3 directories, 6 files, highest UniqueID is 271.
Min read ver. 102, min write ver. 102, max write ver 102.
Recorded by: '*mkisofs' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
Partition reference 0 has 0 of 130879 blocks available.
Length of Implementation use is 46.
End of LVID sequence.
--Partition Descriptor Information:
(M) Partition number 0.
(M) Partition flags: 0001 (Space Allocated)
(M) Impl. ID: '*mkisofs' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
(M) Access Type Read Only.
(M) Partition starts at sector 257.
(M) Partition length is 130879 sectors.
--Implementation Use Volume Descriptor information:
(M) Impl. ID: '*UDF LV Info', UDF Ver.: 01.02 OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
(M) Logical Volume Identifier: 'dvd_pedrinho'
(M) Logical Volume Info 1: ''
(M) Logical Volume Info 2: ''
(M) Logical Volume Info 3: ''
(M) Impl. ID: '*mkisofs' OS: 0,0 (Undefined)
--Volume space report:
16 : 20 - Volume Recognition Sequence
32 : 47 - Main VDS (Front AVDP)
48 : 63 - Reserve VDS (Front AVDP)
64 : 65 - Integrity Sequence
256 : 256 - Front AVDP
257 : 131135 - A partition
131283 : 131283 - Back AVDP
--File Space report:
**[00000001] Expected Tag ID of 256, found 8.
Displaying directory hierarchy:
0000:00000002: \
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf70, ADlength=8, info_length=136]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=3, len=136, file_length=0] [file_length=136]
ICB 0:00002 offset 0
+0000:00000002: [parent] NAME OK parent location OK
ICB 0:00002 offset 28
+0000:00000004: 'AUDIO_TS'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf04, ADlength=8, info_length=40]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=5, len=40, file_length=0]
[file_length=40] ( 40)
ICB 0:00004 offset 0
+0000:00000002: [parent] NAME OK parent location OK
ICB 0:00004 offset 28
++End of directory
ICB 0:00002 offset 58
+0000:00000006: 'VIDEO_TS'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf04, ADlength=8, info_length=352]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=7, len=352, file_length=0]
[file_length=352] ( 352)
ICB 0:00006 offset 0
+0000:00000002: [parent] NAME OK parent location OK
ICB 0:00006 offset 28
-0000:00000008: 'VIDEO_TS.IFO'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=12288]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=21, len=12288, file_length=0]
[file_length=12288] ( 12288)
ICB 0:00006 offset 5c
-0000:00000009: 'VIDEO_TS.BUP'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=12288]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=47, len=12288, file_length=0]
[file_length=12288] ( 12288)
ICB 0:00006 offset 90
-0000:0000000a: 'VTS_01_0.BUP'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=20480]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=130868, len=20480, file_length=0]
[file_length=20480] ( 20480)
ICB 0:00006 offset c4
-0000:0000000b: 'VTS_01_0.IFO'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=20480]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=53, len=20480, file_length=0]
[file_length=20480] ( 20480)
ICB 0:00006 offset f8
-0000:0000000c: 'VTS_01_0.VOB'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=31948800]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=63, len=31948800, file_length=0]
[file_length=31948800] ( 31948800)
ICB 0:00006 offset 12c
-0000:0000000d: 'VTS_01_1.VOB'
[type=SHORT, ad_start=0x805bf24, ADlength=8, info_length=235939840]
[ad_offset=0, atype=0, loc=15663, len=235939840, file_length=0]
[file_length=235939840] ( 235939840)
ICB 0:00006 offset 160
++End of directory
ICB 0:00002 offset 88
++End of directory
--Testing link counts.
There are 3 directories and 6 files.
0 FIDs had a wrong location value.
--Checking Unique ID list.
The maximum Unique ID is 131125.
**The Integrity Descriptor indicated a maximum Unique ID of 270.
I can note that the following
**(R) Volume Set ID: '55D5E6BD0000545A'
does not appear with a compliant volume.
Thanks for your attention.
--
Jonatã Bolzan Loss
On Thu, Aug 20, 2015 at 11:40 AM, Joerg Schilling
<joerg.schill...@fokus.fraunhofer.de> wrote:
> Jonatã Bolzan <jon...@jonata.org> wrote:
>
>> > I am not sure, could you please repeat the description for that problem?
>>
>> "The ECMA specifications support the use of a Reserve Volume
>> Descriptor Sequence (Reserve VDS) as a backup to the Main Volume
>> Descriptor Sequence (Main VDS). When the Reserve VDS is recorded, it
>> must be equivalent to the Main VDS. This rule indicates that two
>> Volume Descriptor Sequences are not equivalent.
>>
>> Since the Reserve VDS is a backup to the Main VDS, technically this
>> should not cause any playability problems as long as the Reserve VDS
>> does not need to be used. However, since there are differences in the
>> interpretation of the file system specifications by different playback
>> systems, it is unknown if this problem will have any effect.
>>
>> Type: UDF
>> Reference: ECMA 167 3/28.4.23, BR-ROm UO0-057 & UO0-050"
>
> OK, didn't we finish with this discussion already?
>
> mkisofs creates such a backup VDS and I believe it does in a compliant way.
>
> Jörg
>
> --
> EMail:jo...@schily.net (home) Jörg Schilling D-13353
> Berlin
> joerg.schill...@fokus.fraunhofer.de (work) Blog:
> http://schily.blogspot.com/
> URL: http://cdrecord.org/private/
> http://sourceforge.net/projects/schilytools/files/'
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
Cdrtools-developers mailing list
Cdrtools-developers@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/cdrtools-developers
