Hi,

> reading Ecma-167 I am not sure if the UDF implementation
> in mkisofs is correct.
> 
> The standard claims that the cvolume recognition area should
> start at sector 16 and be sorted in a way that the first byte
> is in ascending order.

Says where?

> Shouldn't this imply this order:
> 
> 0  CD001
> 0  BEA01
> 0  NSR02
> 0  TEA01
> FF CD001

?? Why not "0 BEA01," "0 CD001," ..., "FF CD001" then? Well, the answer
is no, see "8.3.1.1 CD-ROM Volume Descriptor Set:"

"A CD-ROM Volume Descriptor Set shall be a set of consecutively recorded
Volume Structure Descriptors whose Standard Identifier fields shall not
contain 'BEA01' and shall be interpreted according to ECMA-119."

> while mkisofs writes:
> 
> 0  CD001
> FF CD001
> 0  BEA01
> 0  NSR02
> 0  TEA01

Which is the correct order. A.


-- 
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to