> -----Original Message----- > From: Scott Preece <sepre...@yahoo.com> > > MPPWG was the Mobile Phone Profile Working Group, which I led in an ill-fated > effort to define an open API for phones built on Linux, > back before Android swept the field. We did have talks at a couple ELCs.
Hey Scott! It's good to hear from you. I hope you are doing well! It's been a few years since we used the MPPWG acronym, but I should have remembered it. -- Tim > On Tuesday, August 18, 2020, 4:47 PM, Tim Bird <tim.b...@sony.com> wrote: > > Please find below my feedback on the proposed category list > > > > -----Original Message----- > > > From: Tim Bird > > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > > > From: Amit Agarwal > > > > > > > > > > Overall - Is each item below intended to be a standalone page, or > > is the intent that sub-topics will be sections within a top-level page? > > > Some of the sub-topics (e.g. RealTime) really are big enough to have > > their own top-level page (or even several pages). > > > Maybe this will depend on the number of talks that end up on a page? > > > > Here is the proposed category list: > > > * Linux General > > > ** Status Check > > I'm not sure what "Status Check" is - can you give an example talk in > this category, > > or describe it more? > > > > ** Upstreaming > > > ** Community > > > ** Development process > > Maybe add "Legal" here? > > > > ** LTSI > > LTSI might go better under "distributions"?, but I'm not sure. > > > > * [[Buildsystems]] > > > ** Yocto > > > ** Buildroot > > > ** Bitbake > > There are lots more: OpenWRT, Embedded Debian, Debos, etc. > > How would you categorize ELBE, which builds binary distributions from > Debian? > > Would it go on this page? > > > > * Scheduler > > I'm not sure I see scheduler as a top-level page. I'm not sure how many > > scheduler talks we've had. Power-management scheduling was a big > > topic for a while (e.g. big.LITTLE), but maybe going back farther there > > were lots of talks when the O(1) scheduler was introduced. > > > > ** Real Time > > RealTime is big enough to deserve it's own top-level page. > > Likely, Scheduler is not big enough to deserve it's own top-level page. > > In fact, RealTime might deserve two pages: one for PREEMPT_RT > > and the other for dual-kernel approaches (e.g. Xenomai) > > > > ** Interrupt latency > > > ** Optimizations > > > * Boot Loaders > > > ** U-Boot > > Also BareBox > > > > * Boot Time > > > ** Initialization > > > ** Boot Time optimization > > > * Device Drivers > > > ** How to write a device driver? > > > ** User Space Device Drivers, Optimizations > > > ** UIO > > > * Size > > > ** Kernel Size – Reduction > > > ** Source code > > I'm not sure what the "Source code" category is here. > > > > * File Systems > > > Does "IO scheduling" go here? > > > > * Flash Storage > > > ** NAND Flash > > > ** eMMC > > > * Networking > > > ** Ethernet > > > ** Wi-Fi > > > ** BlueTooth > > > ** X-Ref – IoT relevant topics here (see below) > > > * Security > > > ** SELinux > > Security divides into multiple categories. There are mandatory access > control > > systems, like SELinux, AppArmor, Smack, Tomoyo. And then there are > different > > aspects of security like: > > ** Secure Boot > > ** Cryptography > > ** Trusted stores (TPM) > > ** Hardening > > > > * Upgrades > > > ** OTA updates > > > ** Firmware upgrades > > > * Legal > > OK - maybe this should be a standalone page, but it's kind of in the > > non-technical category of pages. > > > * Multimedia > > > ** Audio > > > ** Video > > > ** Codecs > > > ** GStreamer > > > ** V4L2 (X-Ref with V4L2 kernel sub-system) > > > * Architecture > > > ** ARM > > > ** RISC-V > > > ** PowerPC > > We need Intel or x86 as well (and maybe mips) > > > * Compilers > > > ** GCC, GLIBC > > ** LLVM/Clang > > > ** Linkers, Loaders > > > ** Compiler Optimizations > > > * Device Tree > > > * Kernel sub-systems > > > ** I2C > > > ** SPI > > > ** USB > > > ** Video4linux (V4L2) > > > ** MIPI-DSI > > > ** GPIO > > > ** MTD > > > * Scheduling > > Don't we already have Scheduling above? > > > > * Memory Management > > > ** Virtual Memory > > > ** Process Memory > > > ** TLB > > > * Power Management > > > * SMP > > > ** Multi-core > > > ** Concurrency, Locks > > > * Testing > > > ** Automation > > > ** Fuego > > I would put Fuego underneath a sub-category of > > ** Test Frameworks > > *** Fuego, KernelCI, Kselftest, > > > I would add: > > ** Board farms and infrastructure > > > * Embedded > > > ** MPPWG > > Not sure what "MPPWG" is. > > > > ** Digital STB > > > ** Linux enabled Light bulbs, > > > * Porting > > > * Tools and Debugging > > > ** GDB > > > ** KGDB > > > ** JTAG > > > ** Tracing -- LTTng > > Add ftrace here. > > > * Distributions > > > ** Tomoyo > > I thought Tomoyo was a security system, not a distro, but I could be > wrong. > > > > ** Android > > > ** OpenWRT > > > ** OpenHardware > > > ** uCLinux > > > * Virtualization > > > ** QEMU > > > ** Xen > > > * Robotics > > > ** Drones > > I'm not sure > > > * Miscellaneous > > > ** FOSS > > Legal could also go here? > > > > * Applications > > This category seems to be "Development Tools", not applications. > > > > ** SDK > > > ** Qt Development Framework > > > ** Web development, API development > > > ** HTTP > > > ** Maemo Platform – from Nokia > > > ** Eclipse IDE – Open Development Platform > > > * Graphics > > > ** OpenGL > > > ** DigitalFB > > > * Application Protocols > > I think I'd stick these under "networking", but some are higher-level > protocols. > > > > ** UPnP > > > ** Protocols like UDP/TCP/IP/HTTP/SOAP/SSDP/XML/GENA/SCPD, SIP, IM, > XMPP > > > * Open Source Projects > > I don't think that "Open Source Projects" is a good category for these > sub-topics: > > > > ** Zephyr > > We should probably have a "non-Linux RTOS" page. I think there have > been several > > different talks over the years for non-Linux OSes (NuttX, Zephyr, Free > RTOS, etc.) > > > > ** BeagleBone Board > > > ** Dragon Board > > > ** Nine-Dollar Computer CHIP, > > We should have a "Hardware" category for these board-specific talks. > > > > > > > Good to have different page for following topics with links provided > from the Main Page > > > > > > VERTICALS > > > > > > * Automotive > > > ** V2X > > > ** AGL > > > ** Xen > > > * IoT > > > ** IIoT - Embedded Linux in Industrial IoT > > > ** Embedded Protocols – MQTT, 6lowpan > > These should be under networking > > > > ** Stream Processing for IoT > > > ** Home Automation Tools > > I think I'd put "Home Automation" as it's own topic (not under IoT) > > > maybe also add "Embedded Industrial Systems" as a topic? > > > > ** X-Ref selected topics/presentations with Networking Category (See > above) > > > * Defense Systems > > > I'd put Robotics and Drones under verticals. > > > -- Tim > > > > > > -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#1239): https://lists.celinuxforum.org/g/Celinux-dev/message/1239 Mute This Topic: https://lists.celinuxforum.org/mt/76271481/21656 Group Owner: celinux-dev+ow...@lists.celinuxforum.org Unsubscribe: https://lists.celinuxforum.org/g/Celinux-dev/unsub [arch...@mail-archive.com] -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
