>>
>>
>> While the apologists claim that there were no trauma from the SERE training
>> volunteers, there is now enough research out to say otherwise.
>
>
>Irrelevant to the current question.

No its very relevant, that's one of the justfications given in those memos for 
using torture. One of the authors specifically modified the definitions of 
torture to read no extreme long term psychological trauma. Then he justified 
using the modified SERE techniques by claiming that there was no trauma 
associated with these methods, as supposedly evidenced by no ptsd associated 
with these methods. Obviously that is incorrect.

>
>>
>> Wait a second you're saying that torture is morally justifiable? Krist, we
>> executed people for doing the exact same thing to Americans in the second
>> world war. What is the difference here? Or are you saying that Americans are
>> automatically morally superior to other that they are allowed to torture
>> others?
>>
>
>No, I am saying that when confronted with a choice between the evil of
>roughing these guys up and the evil of seeing
>another attack- which we now know would have entailed the destruction of
>downtown Los Angeles - we made the right choice.

You really ought to stop watching 24. It has little to do with reality.

The dichotomy between torture and a so called smoking hole is a false 
justfication. its's like you saying that by your pissing in potted plants you 
prevent dinosaur attacks. The justification is that there have been no dinosaur 
attacks since you started urinating on potted plants.

>
>I take it you would rather have seen downtown LA destroyed. Or are you
>suggesting that some miracle, a deus ex machina, would have intervened to
>save LA from destruction?
>

What evidence do you have to support your fantasy? Even the intelligence chief 
says that torture doesn't work (http://tinyurl.com/intelligenceChiefTorture)
"The information gained from these techniques was valuable in some instances," 
he said in a statement yesterday, "but there is no way of knowing whether the 
same information could have been obtained through other means." 

Moreover its just not all that effective. The victim will say anything just to 
stop the pain. 

The point being, and what most interrogation specialists, from WWII on through 
the 1991 Gulf War  have been almost unanimous about this, torture is almost 
useless. The best way to get the information you need is to establish a 
relationship with the person you are interrogating and then work from there. 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|
Adobe® ColdFusion® 8 software 8 is the most important and dramatic release to 
date
Get the Free Trial
http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;207172674;29440083;f

Archive: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/groups/cf-community/message.cfm/messageid:295749
Subscription: http://www.houseoffusion.com/groups/cf-community/subscribe.cfm
Unsubscribe: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/unsubscribe.cfm?user=11502.10531.5

Reply via email to