On Fri, Apr 24, 2009 at 11:13 AM, Jerry Johnson wrote: > > need some parameters answered for me to understand the sides here. can > each of you answer these? > > > 1. is waterboarding torture (me, yes).
Sure looks like torture (re: porn, and knowing it when you see it-- but I guess by our own definition, too) > 2. is waterboarding extra-legal or illegal, or is it fine? (me, illegal) Due to #1, illegal. There's a lot more to why it's wrong than the legal aspect tho. Making it legal wouldn't make it right. > 3. if legal, in what circumstances? Ticking bomb cases? general > interrogation of terrorists? general interrogation? Never legal. If I were in an episode of 24, and I was the president, I'd pardon Jack tho. Hell, I'd do whatever I could to help him (he *is* a bad-ass), and be willing to go to jail for it. I would not try to cover it up. Let me be judged by my peers- I stand by my actions, let the chips fall where they may &c. > 4. who can it be used on? Just people captured in war zones? anyone we > dont like? > 5. can it be used on US citizens? > 6. can it be used for other crimes, like small children kidnapped by > child molester? > 7. can it be used just for life-or-death, or can property crimes be > reason (elf)? Never can it be used. Not legally-- by definition. I'd never in my wildest dreams try to justify it as some "last ditch" effort or whatever. Jack knows what he's doing is wrong. It's actually a pretty big plot piece. Torture is just plain *never acceptable*. It doesn't matter one whit, whether or not we got actionable intelligence. It's all good to talk about this as individuals here on cf-comm, and play with the moral math and whatnot-- but as a country? You'd have to be pretty close to going Stalin-styles, to not have a problem with America saying it doesn't have a problem with torture. That people in the media and whatnot are actually having this argument, like "but maybe it's justifiable if we got good intel", is a pretty fucking sorry state for America to be in. It's *never* justifiable (even when it is). How does the term "state-sponsored torture" sound to you? Do you really want America associated with that term? I will die before I see this grand country brought so low. Mark my words-- if I couldn't get rid of state-sponsored torture through the existing system, I'd fucking join or start a revolution, and die trying. This is an easy one: *torture is never acceptable.* At least, not that kind of torture. MS Outlook, license-plate making, "I want my baby-back, baby-back, baby-back" forever without getting to "ribs", my posts here, and torture like that? -- figure it out in court. Water-boarding, bamboo under the nails, shit like that? *FUCKING NEVER!* =] -- We are all, in a sense, experts on secrecy. From earliest childhood we feel its mystery and attraction. We know both the power it confers and the burden it imposes. We learn how it can delight, give breathing space and protect. Sissela Bok ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~| Adobe® ColdFusion® 8 software 8 is the most important and dramatic release to date Get the Free Trial http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;207172674;29440083;f Archive: http://www.houseoffusion.com/groups/cf-community/message.cfm/messageid:295998 Subscription: http://www.houseoffusion.com/groups/cf-community/subscribe.cfm Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/unsubscribe.cfm?user=89.70.5
