> > If a mugger is willing to kill you, you think it's
> > acceptable to kill him?
>
> Desireable to kill him?  no.  Acceptable, yes.

This is where our societies differ - in the UK it's not acceptable to
kill - EVER... You kill someone, even in defense, you go to jail...

> > My point was that it's only a small step to go from "Kill all
> > terrorists" to "Kill terrorists before they attack us" to "Kill the
> > terrorists before they have a chance to become terrorists"
> > - this begets genocide
>
> I dont' subscribe to Kill All Terrorists, but its not a small
> step, its a huge assumption on your part

You may not, but the US government certainly does - and they way they
were attacking the Afghan's, they certainly appeared to be using the
"Kill them before they attack us" technique - it doesn't seem such a
small step to me... You start down that rocky road, there's not much you
can do to back-track

> > The attacks on Afghanistan were killing innocent people,
> > yet in the name of hunting down Al Qaeda it was acceptable
>
> "Acceptable?"  who said it was "acceptable"?  It was entirely
> undesireable.

>From the way the US was bombing Afghanistan, since they didn't know
exactly where the terrorists were, they were almost deliberately
attacking the general populous... Thus the attitude

> > You take that on one step further, it's acceptable to
> > commit genocide in the name of hunting terrorists...
> > Why not go the whole hog and just kill the innocents
> > before they have a chance to BECOME terrorists?
>
> Now THATS a ridiculous statement that its acceptable to
> commit genocide in the name of hunting terrorists.

So you think that killing the general population of Afghanistan by
trying to weed out the Al Qaeda ISN'T attempted genocide? So, the fact
they got in the way was probably their own fault, right?

There were villages and towns destroyed during the bombings - did the US
military inform the population that they were going to bomb them? I very
much doubt it... Therefore they were TRYING to kill the innocents who
happen to get in the way...

> This is what genocide means:
> : the deliberate and systematic destruction of a racial, political, or
> cultural group
>
> Unless you mean that genocide was committed on the political
> group al qaida?
> There was no deliberate and systematic destruction of
> Afghanistani citizens.

Only because they stopped... They were working their way across
Afghanistan, destroying whole areas to get to either the Taliban or the
Al Qaeda - if innocents got in the way, too bad... What does that sound
like to you?

Philip Arnold
Technical Director
Certified ColdFusion Developer
ASP Multimedia Limited
Switchboard: +44 (0)20 8680 8099
Fax: +44 (0)20 8686 7911

www.aspmedia.co.uk
www.aspevents.net

An ISO9001 registered company.

**********************************************************************
This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and
intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they
are addressed. If you have received this email in error please notify
the system manager.
**********************************************************************


______________________________________________________________________
Get the mailserver that powers this list at http://www.coolfusion.com

Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to