Nick McClure wrote:
> http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=578&u=/nm/20020701/ts_nm
> /news_un_court_dc_1

Maybe it is time I give some background on my opinion on the ICC instead 
of just questioning the opinion of others :)

My main point: what's the big deal? What really changes? Does anything 
change at all?

Anybody can sue anybody for charges against humanity in Belgium for a 
decade already. And Belgium is willing to press charges and ask for 
arrests. So whatever the Belgians were doing in their own, non regulated 
ways, is now being regulated and supported by more countries. Nothing 
new there.

As the final verdict by the highest legal authority of the UK in the 
extradiction case of Pinochet has established extraterritorial 
legislation (like international treaties etc) can be a reason for 
prosecution in the UK. (He was returned home because he was unfit for 
trial.) Nothing new there.

Spain is obviously asking for extradiction of people that have been 
accused of crimes against humanity. Nothing new there.

For now, very little changes with the ICC. If anything, it limits 
countries in what they will prosecute themselves, with their own made up 
rules, before asking the ICC to handle it. And the ICC appears to have 
the most strict denominator of rules about evidence etc., with the 
rights of the suspect being protected better as in the US (according to 
the guy that did the negotiations on behalf of the US).
What's the big deal if some countries choose to bundle and formalize 
their existing legislation and have it handled by an expert court? Why 
would that hurt more than what they do now?

As I have said before, I see issues with the ICC. But they are all 
related to the special relation between the ICC and the country where it 
is located. No special status/jurisdiction is established. So what 
happens when a Dutch national is held for the ICC? Is that even possible 
under Dutch law? How about a Dutch national being convicted by the ICC 
and to be imprisoned in Finland (that appears to be where Milosevic is 
heading)? Is that possible under Dutch law? That is the kind of problems 
I foresee.

But I see no problem in a group of countries bundling their existing 
legislation and having it handled by 1 court.

Jochem

______________________________________________________________________
Structure your ColdFusion code with Fusebox. Get the official book at 
http://www.fusionauthority.com/bkinfo.cfm

Archives: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/
Unsubscribe: http://www.houseoffusion.com/index.cfm?sidebar=lists

Reply via email to