Jochem --

See my comments in line

Andy Ousterhout wrote:
> I can understand being against all war and I believe that almost everyone
> is against war in general.  Just for background, I am for the war only
> because I just don't see any alternative.  Either we fight now on our
> terms while he is relatively weak or we fight later on his terms
> resulting in exponentially more deaths on both sides.

Jochem -- If we extrapolate that to say the guy living on the next block who
has done
his time for child molest and has a high probability to do it again this
reasoning means you are in favour of doing what to him exactly? (Purely
preventively of course.) And what to a thief that has done his time?

Or do you see an alternative in those cases?

ACO Writes:  Actually, I see a better analogy that you have a child molester
next door who has done his time and as part of his getting out of jail,
agreed to stay away from schools and he is now hanging out by the local
grade school.  Or the parole who is supposed to check in every week who
doesn't.  In each case, if they have broken the rules on which their freedom
is based, I would revoke their freedom.  If they resist arrest, I would use
force.

..........

> 1.  Assuming that many innocents are dying today in Iraq that would not
> die under a new US-supported regime, is it "more" moral to sit by and
> watch large number of innocents die or to fight a war were some will
> surely die to stop the ongoing deaths?

Jochem -- Not if that was the only moral consideration.

ACO - So what would you do in this case if it was your call -- sit by and
watch more people die or go in and cause some people to die?

> 2.  Are current UN sanctions that result in these deaths because of the
> way that Saddam is implementing them moral?  If not, what alternatives
> does a world body have to implement agreed to policy against him?

Jochem -- Yes.
You want just alternatives or alternatives that I find moral?

ACO -  How about alternatives that you believe might be workable and that
you would support.  We can have the moral discussions later if any create
any moral dilemma's for folks.

>3.  Is there ever an appropriate use of deadly force and if so, under what
>constraints?

Jochem -- Yes. Apart from the self-defence case constraints are determined
by the Utility function.

ACO -- Utility function???

........

Jochem - Is it right to undertake actions the results of which will be felt
by those
who have not consented with those actions?

ACO - Very, very good question.  First of all, all of our actions effect
others who have not consented.  The good and bad news is that all of our
lives are intertwined.  Clearly there are cases where the answer is yes -
parent/child relationships for example.  There are equally easy no's - If I
want to smoke a cigarette by myself, with no one around to be bothered by
second hand smoke, then no one has the right to say I can't, even though
this increases the likelihood of higher medical expenses( I like this one
because it does have the potential to impact others through healthcare
implications).  However, most others are in the middle, covered in gray,
highly subjective to the position of the person commenting.  I am not sure
that Society as we know it could exist if the answer was no. Of course, this
leads us to discuss consent.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|
Archives: http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/index.cfm?forumid=5
Subscription: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/index.cfm?method=subscribe&forumid=5
This list and all House of Fusion resources hosted by CFHosting.com. The place for 
dependable ColdFusion Hosting.

                                Unsubscribe: 
http://www.houseoffusion.com/cf_lists/unsubscribe.cfm?user=89.70.5
                                

Reply via email to