From: "Ben Braver" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "CF-Community" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Wednesday, February 04, 2004 1:47 PM
Subject: Re:Monk (was Re:Law and Order)
> Gee, Charlie, you don't have it figured out halfway through?
> <j/k>
>
> But a lot of times there are clues beforehand -
> like the one with the political assassination,
> where Monk is thoughtfully looking at the loop
> in the window blind cord...
ok...i'm thinking specifically about the one with the elephant/trapeze
artist (i think it was a fairly recent episode)...
and just in case it's warranted (better to err on the side of
caution).......
*************SPOIKER ***********************************
So Monk is *convinced* it's the woman in the wheelchair with the shattered
leg. And *we* even know it's her, as we see her place the radio transmitter
behind the elephant's ear (the guy's head getting squished, btw, was
hysterical). So Monk (and the audience) has to figure out how this woman
with a shattered leg could have killed her husband and cartwheeled away.
Yes, she dropped a clue, when she said "the first thing you learn is how to
fall"...but I think it was kind of ...again, rather "Hardy Boys" or
"Encyclopedia Brown" in the conclusions. Without that one sentence, there
was no logical jump of any kind to come to the conclusion that she didn't
break her leg during the fall, but did so *afterwards* with the help of the
elephant (and the part about using the elephant to break the leg seemed like
even more of a quantum leap in assumption).
Yeah, I still really enjoy the show. The characters are great and the
actors/actresses do a great job of bringing them to life. Sometimes tho, I
just wait for Parker Stevenson and Shaun Cassidy </obscure reference> to
jump in to help out : )
spoiker? : )
[Todays Threads] [This Message] [Subscription] [Fast Unsubscribe] [User Settings]
