http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/04/27/asia/indo.php


Indonesia and Singapore sign two landmark treaties



JAKARTA: Indonesia and Singapore signed two landmark treaties on defense and 
extradition Friday that will give the city-state access to the space it needs 
to train its military and Jakarta the chance to bring some high-profile 
business fugitives to justice and recoup a fortune in bank funds embezzled 
during the economic crisis a decade ago.
The treaties, signed on the Indonesian resort island of Bali in the presence of 
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyonon of Indonesia, Prime Minister Lee Hsien 
Loong of Singapore and several ministers, are a potential turning point in an 
occasionally testy relationship between the two neighbors.

Before the ceremony Friday, Foreign Minister Hassan Wirajuda of Indonesia said 
in an interview that the treaties represented a "very significant step" forward 
because they resolved issues that had been a "constraint" on the warmth of 
relations between the two countries.

For Indonesia, the introduction of an extradition treaty removes a persistent 
irritant in relations with Singapore. It has sought an extradition treaty since 
the mid-1970s as it has watched large numbers of Indonesian businesspeople 
accused of corruption flee to Singapore.

Indonesian officials have signaled that they will try to seek the return of as 
many as 18 businesspeople once the treaties are ratified by the Parliaments of 
the two countries, which is expected. Several of these individuals are 
implicated in the embezzlement of hundreds of millions of dollars from 
Indonesian banks during the 1997-98 economic crisis.


The Indonesian government views the existence of extradition arrangements as a 
major plank in its anti-corruption fight. But the treaty might be of greater 
significance for its contribution to the domestic political debate over 
corruption than practical law enforcement.
Analysts say the time that will pass before the treaty is ratified and when it 
will take effect will allow the targets of extradition to prepare their legal 
defense or find alternative refuges. They say Singapore's banking secrecy laws 
are also quite likely to ensure that Indonesia will face a hard and lengthy 
legal battle to retrieve any of the proceeds of corruption.

Still, the existence of the treaty and the prospect of bringing some of the 
fugitives back from Singapore to face trial in Indonesia will reinforce the 
government's message that it will be consistent in pursing its anti-corruption 
efforts.

"People here believe that Singapore has become a safe haven for criminals, 
particularly economic criminals, and that this has placed them beyond the law," 
Theo Sambuaga, chairman of the foreign affairs committee of the Indonesian 
Parliament, said in an interview. He added that the treaty "will support our 
anti-corruption drive."

Singaporean officials have disputed the extent to which Indonesians have parked 
corrupt funds believed to be corrupt in the city's banks. But a report last 
year by Merrill Lynch and Capgemini estimated that one-third of high net-worth 
investors in Singapore were of Indonesian origin. It estimated that some 18,000 
wealthy Indonesians had assets of $87 billion invested there, although only a 
handful would be of interest to Indonesian law enforcement officials.

Singapore has been accused of dragging its feet over the negotiation of the 
treaty. It has been trying to promote itself has a clean and safe environment 
for the ultrarich, where the confidentiality of their investments will be 
protected.

Wirajuda, the foreign minister, said the conclusion of negotiations could be a 
springboard to increased cooperation between the two countries on a range of 
issues.

"The fact that this issue for so long has not been resolved has created a 
perception that Singapore hasn't been cooperating with us," he said. "I think 
the conclusion and signing of these agreements creates a momentum for the two 
countries to expand the bilateral relationship."

The defense treaty signed Friday is widely seen here as a trade-off for 
Singapore's agreement to extradition. The city-state lacks land and airspace to 
effectively train its military and has sought agreements with others in the 
region to provide training grounds. Indonesia offers the ideal solution because 
of its huge land and maritime area.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke