http://www.thejakartapost.com/detaileditorial.asp?fileid=20070528.F03&irec=2
Let's strengthen corruption fight in second half Mas Achmad Santosa and Nenad Bago, Jakarta Over the last two years President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has taken a number of concrete steps to fulfill campaign promises to introduce good governance and combat corruption. First, he issued a 2004 presidential instruction on fighting corruption and followed up with a national action plan. Second, in 2005 he established the Coordinating Team to Eradicate Corruption (Timtastikor). It handles special corruption cases within government agencies and state-owned enterprises. Third, the President has given permission to investigate and prosecute high-ranking public officers as requested by the police and the Attorney General's Office. Under the President's leadership we have witnessed a steady increase in the number of corruption cases prosecuted and the total assets recovered. During 2006 the Attorney General's Office alone prosecuted 679 corruption cases, or 266 more cases than in 2005 (Report from AGO's Special Crime, 2006). The assets recovered in 2006 amounted to Rp 2.3 trillion (US$255 million). The Timtastikor reported this month that it has recaptured Rp 3.95 trillion in its two years of operation (Kompas, April 30, 2007). These punitive measures delivered a message that corruption is no longer a risk-free endeavor in Indonesia. During 2006 the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) completed pre-investigations of 36 cases, fully investigated 18 cases, and prosecuted 10. Since its establishment, the KPK has won convictions in 13 cases. However, the recoverable assets were only Rp 27.7 billion. Less than half of those assets have been transferred to the state treasurer (KPK Annual Report, 2006). Despite this improvement, the opportunities for corruption and collusion at the local level of government remain large. This is due to two main factors. First, local governments lack strategies to reduce corruption. Second, the police, public prosecutors and judiciary lack the capacity to effectively handle a large number of corruption cases in a independent and efficient manner. The Indonesian judiciary also has an important role in convincing the public that the potential cost of engaging in corruption outweighs the benefits. During 2006 the Supreme Court has had the final word on 307 out of 499 corruption-related cases. A total of 239, or 78 percent, resulted in conviction and 68 in acquittal (Supreme Court Annual Report, 2006). While the number of corruption cases which ended in conviction seems considerable, the amount of assets recovered is comparatively small. In Nigeria, the Economic and Financial Crime Commission alone has successfully recovered $5 billion through 82 corruption-related convictions within 3 years of its establishment. The 22 percent of cases that ended in acquittal will need to be carefully analyzed in order to understand the cause of each decision. Was it a poor-quality investigation and prosecution? Or did the judges fail to oversee the case in an impartial manner? Or both? If the problem is within the judiciary, than the Supreme Court needs to proceed with the certification of judges to ensure that those who handle corruption cases have a sufficient level of integrity and professionalism. Although the 2004 presidential instruction also focuses on the need to improve public services to reduce red tape, a recent government report regarding public services in 10 districts and municipalities did not show significant improvement. The report also concluded that the instruction had not been implemented by national, regional and local government agencies. In order to turn around the public perception of the anti-corruption effort in the second half of their term, the President and Vice President need to focus on at least three areas: First, they must show that their full political will is behind the effort to investigate and prosecute corruption cases involving large amounts of assets and alleged perpetrators - even if the cases involve persons closely associated with them. Second, they should launch bureaucratic reforms by developing a concrete and detailed action plan for change and initiating pilot projects in national and provincial agencies. Third, the President needs to reevaluate the effectiveness of the 2004 presidential instruction, particularly the part that provides a legal basisup" the law enforcement agencies, including the basis to take concrete action to increase the salary of the law enforcement officers based on their performance. There is limited time available to turn around negative public perceptions of this effort before a semi-successful story becomes a political burden in the upcoming presidential campaign. The authors are anti-corruption and legal reform experts at UNDP-Indonesia. [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
