http://www.atimes.com/atimes/China_Business/IF08Cb01.html

SPEAKING FREELY



Enjoy dying while it lasts
By Thomas Palley 



Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov, alias Lenin, was the leader of the 1917 Bolshevik 
Revolution in Russia. One of his best-known quotes is: "The capitalists will 
sell us the rope with which we will hang them." Today, Lenin must be chuckling 
in his Moscow mausoleum as he watches US business dealings with China. 

Lenin's sarcastic quip identified how desire for profit can sometimes undermine 
class interest. In today's era of globalization, a similar logic can hold for 
the national interest. Thus, with corporations looking to maximize their global 
profits, what is good for profit can sometimes be bad for country. 

US-China relations provide a case study of the "profit vs country" dilemma. 
Current US-China economic relations are marked by huge US trade deficits and a 
steady migration of manufacturing to China. This structure was established in 
the 1990s at the behest of multinational corporations and big retailers such as 
Wal-Mart. The former saw China as providing an unequaled low-cost production 
platform from which to export to the US, while the latter saw China as a source 
of low-cost imports. 

Together, these business interests pushed permanent normal trading relations 
(PNTR) for China, and they also explain the US Treasury's willingness to accept 
China's undervalued exchange rate. That is because an undervalued yuan holds 
down the cost of goods sourced from China and increases profits on production 
exported from there. 

For China, the new arrangements have contributed to spectacular economic 
success. Companies sourcing and exporting from China have also reaped handsome 
profits. However, for the US economy it has been a different story. 
Manufacturing has steadily bled jobs as companies have closed factories in the 
face of low-cost Chinese competition, and production and investment have 
shifted to China. That has tempered wages and investment spending, which helps 
to explain the weak US economic recovery and unsatisfactory expansion. It has 
also eroded the US industrial base while expanding China's, thereby creating 
new national-security problems for the United States. 

Through its trade surpluses, China has accumulated US$1.2 trillion of 
foreign-exchange reserves - mostly held in US Treasury bills. Recently, China 
announced that it will invest some of those funds in US equities, signaling the 
beginning of a new chapter that promises to entrench existing US policy 
further. 

This is because the new initiative will deepen Wall Street's support for 
current US policy by offering the prospect of huge fees and capital gains from 
reinvesting in China's reserves. Consequently, Wall Street will now throw its 
full weight behind existing policy, since the Street recognizes that China 
needs continuing trade surpluses if it is to invest its foreign-exchange 
holdings in risky assets such as equities. That augurs badly for the US and 
Main Street. 

Wall Street's greatest influence is at the Treasury, which has been the leader 
in designing US-China economic policy. The strong-dollar policy originated at 
the Treasury in the 1990s, and it has persistently refused to label China a 
currency manipulator for fear of triggering irresistible public pressure for 
real action. 

On top of this, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson - a Goldman Sachs alumnus - is 
actively advocating policies that risk compounding the damage to the US 
economy. Thus the Treasury has consistently pushed China to open its financial 
markets and let money exit, and China has been doing just that. This benefits 
Wall Street, since money flows there, but it reduces pressure on China to 
appreciate its currency. Worse than that, the yuan could even depreciate if 
enough Chinese wealth-holders decide to exit to diversify their portfolios 
against economic and political risk. That would be disastrous for the US 
economy, but good news for Wall Street. 

The profit vs country dilemma is compounded by the political power of 
corporations, which has enabled them to capture policy. In earlier eras, such 
capture promoted domestic monopoly and corruption in government procurement and 
tax policy. Today, it still does that (look at the administration of President 
George W Bush), but now it also enables corporations to push policies placing 
their interests ahead of country. That is the lesson of China. 

Free-market societies need separation between market and government, 
intermediated by constitutional democracy. In the 20th century, many countries 
suffered from excessive government control over market activities, and they 
paid a heavy price. In the 21st century, the United States risks paying a heavy 
price from the reverse problem of allowing excessive corporate influence over 
government. 

This is a huge danger, yet it is off the political radar. One reason is that 
business funds both main US political parties, Republicans and Democrats, 
thereby silencing both. A second reason is that much of the public believes 
business people are smart and can run government well - after all, they are 
rich. Put the two together, and it is easy to see why business executives move 
seamlessly from Wall Street and corporate boardrooms to top government policy 
offices on Pennsylvania and Constitution avenues. That suggests the supply of 
rope will remain plentiful and Lenin may have the last laugh. 

Thomas Palley is founder of the Economics for Democratic and Open Societies 
Project. 

(Copyright 2007 Thomas I Palley.) 

Speaking Freely is an Asia Times Online feature that allows guest writers to 
have their say. Please click here if you are interested in contributing

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke