Illustration: Nino Jose Heredia/Gulf News
Young Russia's enemy No 1
By Sarah E. Mendelson and Theodore P. Gerber, Los
Angeles Times-Washington Post
Published: August 05, 2007, 23:05
Vladimir Putin's belligerent rhetoric and actions
towards the United States and its allies have begun prompting pundits to debate
whether a new Cold War is afoot.
But how has the Russian president's message played to
his home audience? A survey we commissioned by the Levada Analytic Centre of
1,802 Russians ages 16 to 29 offers some insight. We focused on this "Putin
generation'' because it is Russia's political and economic future.
In the days after the Soviet collapse, it seemed
reasonable to hope, even expect, that this generation, as the collective
beneficiaries of a putative post-Soviet transition to economic prosperity and
political freedom, would embrace the United States as a friend of Russia. Yet
our survey, conducted in April and May, found that a majority of young Russians
view the United States as enemy No 1. And while Putin's rhetoric is driving
this development, human rights violations associated with US counterterrorism
policies have played a role.
Putin has become increasingly vocal in his accusations
that the United States seeks to impose its ideas and interests on the rest of
the world, going so far as to liken American policies to those of the Third
Reich. He frequently cites the "dangers'' of foreign influence, suggesting that
Russia is encircled by enemies and that foreign governments finance Russian
organisations to meddle in Russia's affairs.
Putin virulently rejects any foreign criticism of
episodes from Russia's Soviet past or of such current policies as media
restrictions, brutality in the North Caucasus and the persecution of Kremlin
opponents. This campaign seems motivated by domestic political considerations;
the creation of foreign "enemies'' is a tactic long used to distract people
from the shortcomings of their own government, rally support for authoritarian
measures, or both.
Resonate
But these themes resonate with young Russians. Nearly
80 per cent agreed that "the United States tries to impose its norms and way of
life on the rest of the world,'' we found. Nearly 70 per cent disagreed that
the United States "does more good than harm.'' Three-quarters agreed that the
"United States gives aid in order to influence the internal politics of
countries''.
When asked which of five words best described the
United States in relation to Russia, 64 per cent chose either "enemy'' or
"rival''. We asked the same question in regard to six other countries. Georgia,
another target of Putin's, ranked second in terms of the percentage who chose
these words - but that was only at 44 per cent. The other countries were less
likely to be viewed as enemies or rivals, even though some represent an
arguably equal or greater threat: China (27 per cent), Iran (21 per cent),
Ukraine (21 per cent), Germany (13 per cent) and Belarus (12 per cent).
Substantially more than the 18 per cent who described America as a "partner''
or "ally'' used these positive terms to characterise the other countries.
Putin's rhetoric is an influence on these and two other findings: 54 per cent
agreed that Stalin "did more good than bad'' and 63 per cent agreed that the
Soviet collapse was the "greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the 20th
century''.
We also found that Bush administration counterterrorism
policies have helped the Kremlin cultivate this hostility toward America.
Critics of certain US policies assert that practices departing from
long-standing international law - such as indefinite detention and
extraordinary rendition - are linked to the worldwide decline of America's
reputation and moral sway, key elements of "soft'' power. Our data support
these claims. Respondents tended to believe that the United States tortures
terrorism suspects (52 per cent), renders them to countries that practise
torture (44 per cent) and detains them without due process or legal
representation (46 per cent). Very few respondents - 9 to 13 per cent -
believed these allegations to be false; the rest found it "hard to say.''
Perceptions
Generally, respondents condemned these practices (42 to
57 per cent, with only 15 to 29 per cent approving). Moreover, our statistical
modelling demonstrates that perceptions of American human rights violations
relate directly to anti-American sentiment: Young Russians who believed that
the United States tortures or unlawfully detains terrorist suspects had
considerably more negative views of the US government than those who did not.
The legacy of a new generation of Russians who are
nostalgic for the Soviet Union, ambivalent about Stalin and hostile toward the
United States may jeopardise US-Russian relations long after Putin is gone.
Thus, in addition to countering Putin's aggressive stance in the short term,
this US administration and the next needs to develop longer-term strategies to
reverse the tide of growing anti-American sentiment among young Russians.
Changing US counterterrorism policies is a good place to start. The goal should
be to restore the vision of America expressed by Andrei Sakharov: "In fact, we
don't idealise America and see a lot that is bad or foolish in it, but America
is a vital force, a positive factor in our chaotic world.''
Sarah E. Mendelson directs the Human Rights and
Security Initiative at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies.
Theodore P. Gerber is a professor of sociology at the University of Wisconsin
at Madison
http://www.gulfnews.com/opinion/columns/world/10144393.html
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]