http://www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2007/12/13/006.html
Thursday, December 13, 2007. Issue 3806. Page 8.
Small Democratic Step
By Michael McFaul
For the last eight years of Vladimir Putin's presidency, friends of mine who
either worked for or were simply sympathetic to the Kremlin have argued at
various times that Russia was a "managed" democracy, a "sovereign" democracy or
an autocracy like China on the long road to democracy via the
autocratic-modernizer path. Western observers of Russian internal developments,
including the U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, have echoed this third
argument, emphasizing that Russia's transition from communism to democracy
would be a long one but that it is nonetheless under way.
My response has been twofold. First, these "special" forms of democracy are
just camouflage for anti-democratic actions. To be sure, there are many forms
of democratic rule around the world, and the U.S. system, incidentally, is by
no means the most democratic form of government. But all democracies share a
few fundamental features, including first and foremost competition in elections
for national office and some institutional constraints on those in elected
office. By these simple measures, Russia is clearly less democratic today than
at the beginning of Putin's time in office.
Second, the long road to democracy is not some inevitable course of history
that all countries follow. Rather, real human beings take actions to either
impede or promote democratic practices. Democracy -- or its absence -- is not
made by economic, cultural or historical determinants. Rather, democrats make
democracy, and autocrats prevent it.
Motivated by the centrality of individual action, I have pushed back to my
Putin supporters with the rhetorical question: Name me one Putin policy or
decision over the last eight years that has made the political system more
democratic? Some name the 13 percent flat tax, but this reform was about
economic policy, not governance. Moreover, many might ask if it is democratic
when billionaires pay the same tax rate as factory workers.
Others cite the reform of the electoral law for the State Duma, which
theoretically could have been a democratic reform since we know that electoral
systems based on proportional representation stimulate party development. In
reality, however, the results of the last parliamentary elections demonstrated
that an electoral mandate for Putin -- not the development of political parties
-- was the goal of electoral law reform. Perhaps most absurd, earlier this
month some tried to portray the arrest of opposition leader Garry Kasparov as
an example of the rule of law, since he did "break the law." I was not
convinced by these and other examples of Putin's supposed democratic reforms.
As of Monday, however, I now stand corrected. By committing to stepping down as
president by naming a successor, Putin has taken a small but important step
toward democratization. Since December 1993, political forces of all
ideological persuasions have acquiesced to the political rules of the game
spelled out in the Constitution. Putin's decision to continue to adhere to
these rules will make it more costly for future leaders to transgress them.
Of course, the reason Putin can feel secure in anointing Dmitry Medvedev as his
successor is that Putin and his team have so weakened all other centers of
political power. Could Medvedev win a competitive election campaign against
candidates with financial resources, access to national television and the
ability to win support from regional leaders? We will never know. And this
changing of the guard is more like the strange 1999-2000 transition from
Yeltsin to Putin than a genuine change of government through the electoral
process. U.S. political scientist Adam Przeworski once defined democracy as a
system of government in which incumbents lose elections. That is unlikely to be
the case in March. Finally, the fact that everyone is already convinced that
Medvedev will be the next president -- four months before any votes have been
cast -- underscores just how undemocratic the Russian political system has
become.
Nonetheless, the process of changing leaders now under way in Russia is more
democratic than many alternatives. Perhaps most important, this process leaves
open the possibility of unintended consequences sometime in the future,
including power struggles between the president and the government, or between
the president and a new presidential team that has an appreciation for the
positive consequences of competition, whether it is in the marketplace or the
political arena. But let's not get too excited. A quarter century ago, Kremlin
watchers all got worked up about the fact that the new general secretary, Yury
Andropov, listened to jazz. Similarly, when Medvedev dons a black leather
jacket or listens to Deep Purple, this hardly makes him democratic.
That being said, however, it is a positive sign that Russia will have two
leaders instead of one and that the government will be guided by constitutional
rules. So, congratulations President Putin for your democratic move! May it be
the first of many -- intended or otherwise.
Michael McFaul is a Hoover fellow and professor of political science at
Stanford University and a senior associate at the Carnegie Moscow Center.