http://www.iht.com/articles/2008/04/04/europe/04nato.php
Putin takes a softer tone at NATO summit By Steven Erlanger Friday, April 4, 2008 BUCHAREST: President Vladimir Putin of Russia complained Friday that NATO was not taking Russia's legitimate security concerns into account, but he also said that President George W. Bush was listening to Moscow's criticisms of a planned missile-shield for Europe to be based in the Czech Republic and Poland. In a closed meeting with NATO leaders, Putin was described by officials as both combative and thoughtful, criticizing NATO's promise to eventually make Ukraine and Georgia members. "NATO cannot guarantee its security at the expense of other countries' security," he said, according to one official, and complained that some NATO members, presumably those formerly under Soviet occupation, "went as far as total demonization of Russia and can't get away from this even now." Putin denied that Russia had imperial ambitions, said Moscow wanted cooperation with NATO on joint security problems like Afghanistan and terrorism and agreed with Bush that the Cold War was over, another Western official said. It was Putin's first visit to a NATO summit meeting as the Russian president, and also his last, since he is scheduled to hand over his job in May to Dmitri Medvedev. Putin gave one of his trademark press conferences, taking questions for nearly an hour from the international media in a measured and articulate way. In one of his odder comments about relations with NATO, he told reporters: "Let's be friends, guys, and be frank and open." Putin clearly did not intend to make big waves here, a day before he and Bush meet again in Sochi, Russia, for what is likely to be their last bilateral discussion as presidents. That meeting, he said, would likely center on the proposed missile defense system, which Russia opposes as a threat to its security, despite NATO denials. "We evaluate the results of this meeting as positive," Putin said after the meeting. "The spirit of cooperation and search for compromise prevailed." The NATO secretary general, Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, agreed, saying that Putin did not indulge in the antagonistic language he used against Washington in a speech in Munich in February 2007. "The discussion was frank and open, there was no hiding of views but the spirit was positive," de Hoop Scheffer said. "It is true that NATO enlargement is a contentious issue. The minds do not exactly meet, to put it mildly." But there was no reason to complain about "unhelpful rhetoric," he said. "I think the meeting had a constructive atmosphere. You can expect me to criticize unhelpful rhetoric when it occurs, but it did not occur this morning." As Putin began his press conference, Bush was in a car on the way to the airport and did not answer a question about the tone and substance of the meeting. Flying to Zagreb, Croatia, a senior administration official described the meeting as "very constructive, matter of fact, straightforward." The official, speaking anonymously under White House ground rules, said that Putin's opening and closing remarks to the NATO allies were "very classy," noting the importance of a dialogue on all issues. But the official refused to discuss specific Putin comments, saying only that: "It was pretty clear he wanted to end on a positive note." Bush, speaking directly to Putin in his remarks, described the two of them as "two old war horses," the American official said. Putin's spokesman, Dmitri Peskov, complained that Putin's opening remarks to NATO leaders were not shown to the press on the internal television system, in contrast to the remarks earlier by President Viktor Yushchenko of Ukraine. The Spanish foreign minister, Miguel Ángel Moratinos, said that Putin "showed a willingness for dialogue," saying that Russia would be willing to return to the Conventional Armed Forces in Europe treaty, which sets limits for troops outside sovereign borders, if Western nations are willing to compromise, presumably adjusting the treaty limits. But Putin also called NATO's promise of eventual membership to Georgia and Ukraine "a direct threat" to Russian security. Russian anger, however, was mitigated by the alliance's refusal to back Bush's position that the two aspirant members be welcomed now into the Membership Action Plan, or MAP. The program sets out stiff conditions for NATO membership, including political, military, legal and intelligence reforms. While Bush was supported by some half of NATO's members, including nearly all those of central and eastern Europe, he was opposed by Germany, France, Spain, Italy and others of "old Europe," who believe that the two aspirants are not yet ready for the membership plan, and that such a decision would be an unnecessary blow to Russia. Speaking of Ukraine and Georgia, Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier of Germany said in an interview this week with the Leipziger Volkszeitung that after Russian anger over Kosovo's independence, "we could see no convincing reason to create more tension." The Russian-Ukrainian relationship is historically close, with Moscow dominating Kiev and the Russians regarding the Ukrainians as "little brothers." Those ties were badly strained with the breakup of the Soviet Union, with many Ukrainians in the east wanting to keep closer ties with Russia than those in the west. After a similar meeting Friday with NATO leaders, Yushchenko said his country understood the problems that delayed its bid and remains devoted to democratic and European values. "I'm not a naïve politician, and I clearly understand what debates and challenges we were speaking about," he said. He welcomed the NATO promise of eventual membership and said: "Ukraine is not a product of the Cold War. Ukraine is an independent, sovereign state and it has its own right to formulate its own security policy." Earlier on Friday, another Russian official, Sergei Ryabkov, chief of the Foreign Ministry's department for European cooperation, was more caustic in his remarks to journalists here, insisting that the populations of Ukraine and Georgia were against NATO membership. "We have new concerns about plans to integrate U.S. missile defense plans with NATO system," he said. "We can't sit aside and watch how they rubber-stamp decisions made by other people changing the security situation for Russia." That may foreshadow a harder tone that Putin may use in Sochi. But he seemed eager here not to throw away his partial victory on Ukraine and Georgia by overly aggressive comments. Bush flew from Bucharest to Croatia, which was offered full NATO membership here along with Albania. He will meet with Croatian officials and then fly on Saturday to Sochi for a weekend with Putin. Steven Lee Myers contributed reporting for this article. Putin takes a softer tone at NATO summit By Steven Erlanger Friday, April 4, 2008 BUCHAREST: President Vladimir Putin of Russia complained Friday that NATO was not taking Russia's legitimate security concerns into account, but he also said that President George W. Bush was listening to Moscow's criticisms of a planned missile-shield for Europe to be based in the Czech Republic and Poland. In a closed meeting with NATO leaders, Putin was described by officials as both combative and thoughtful, criticizing NATO's promise to eventually make Ukraine and Georgia members. "NATO cannot guarantee its security at the expense of other countries' security," he said, according to one official, and complained that some NATO members, presumably those formerly under Soviet occupation, "went as far as total demonization of Russia and can't get away from this even now." Putin denied that Russia had imperial ambitions, said Moscow wanted cooperation with NATO on joint security problems like Afghanistan and terrorism and agreed with Bush that the Cold War was over, another Western official said. It was Putin's first visit to a NATO summit meeting as the Russian president, and also his last, since he is scheduled to hand over his job in May to Dmitri Medvedev. Putin gave one of his trademark press conferences, taking questions for nearly an hour from the international media in a measured and articulate way. In one of his odder comments about relations with NATO, he told reporters: "Let's be friends, guys, and be frank and open." Putin clearly did not intend to make big waves here, a day before he and Bush meet again in Sochi, Russia, for what is likely to be their last bilateral discussion as presidents. That meeting, he said, would likely center on the proposed missile defense system, which Russia opposes as a threat to its security, despite NATO denials. "We evaluate the results of this meeting as positive," Putin said after the meeting. "The spirit of cooperation and search for compromise prevailed." The NATO secretary general, Jaap de Hoop Scheffer, agreed, saying that Putin did not indulge in the antagonistic language he used against Washington in a speech in Munich in February 2007. "The discussion was frank and open, there was no hiding of views but the spirit was positive," de Hoop Scheffer said. "It is true that NATO enlargement is a contentious issue. The minds do not exactly meet, to put it mildly." But there was no reason to complain about "unhelpful rhetoric," he said. "I think the meeting had a constructive atmosphere. You can expect me to criticize unhelpful rhetoric when it occurs, but it did not occur this morning." As Putin began his press conference, Bush was in a car on the way to the airport and did not answer a question about the tone and substance of the meeting. Flying to Zagreb, Croatia, a senior administration official described the meeting as "very constructive, matter of fact, straightforward." The official, speaking anonymously under White House ground rules, said that Putin's opening and closing remarks to the NATO allies were "very classy," noting the importance of a dialogue on all issues. But the official refused to discuss specific Putin comments, saying only that: "It was pretty clear he wanted to end on a positive note." Bush, speaking directly to Putin in his remarks, described the two of them as "two old war horses," the American official said. Putin's spokesman, Dmitri Peskov, complained that Putin's opening remarks to NATO leaders were not shown to the press on the internal television system, in contrast to the remarks earlier by President Viktor Yushchenko of Ukraine. The Spanish foreign minister, Miguel Ángel Moratinos, said that Putin "showed a willingness for dialogue," saying that Russia would be willing to return to the Conventional Armed Forces in Europe treaty, which sets limits for troops outside sovereign borders, if Western nations are willing to compromise, presumably adjusting the treaty limits. But Putin also called NATO's promise of eventual membership to Georgia and Ukraine "a direct threat" to Russian security. Russian anger, however, was mitigated by the alliance's refusal to back Bush's position that the two aspirant members be welcomed now into the Membership Action Plan, or MAP. The program sets out stiff conditions for NATO membership, including political, military, legal and intelligence reforms. While Bush was supported by some half of NATO's members, including nearly all those of central and eastern Europe, he was opposed by Germany, France, Spain, Italy and others of "old Europe," who believe that the two aspirants are not yet ready for the membership plan, and that such a decision would be an unnecessary blow to Russia. Speaking of Ukraine and Georgia, Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier of Germany said in an interview this week with the Leipziger Volkszeitung that after Russian anger over Kosovo's independence, "we could see no convincing reason to create more tension." The Russian-Ukrainian relationship is historically close, with Moscow dominating Kiev and the Russians regarding the Ukrainians as "little brothers." Those ties were badly strained with the breakup of the Soviet Union, with many Ukrainians in the east wanting to keep closer ties with Russia than those in the west. After a similar meeting Friday with NATO leaders, Yushchenko said his country understood the problems that delayed its bid and remains devoted to democratic and European values. "I'm not a naïve politician, and I clearly understand what debates and challenges we were speaking about," he said. He welcomed the NATO promise of eventual membership and said: "Ukraine is not a product of the Cold War. Ukraine is an independent, sovereign state and it has its own right to formulate its own security policy." Earlier on Friday, another Russian official, Sergei Ryabkov, chief of the Foreign Ministry's department for European cooperation, was more caustic in his remarks to journalists here, insisting that the populations of Ukraine and Georgia were against NATO membership. "We have new concerns about plans to integrate U.S. missile defense plans with NATO system," he said. "We can't sit aside and watch how they rubber-stamp decisions made by other people changing the security situation for Russia." That may foreshadow a harder tone that Putin may use in Sochi. But he seemed eager here not to throw away his partial victory on Ukraine and Georgia by overly aggressive comments. Bush flew from Bucharest to Croatia, which was offered full NATO membership here along with Albania. He will meet with Croatian officials and then fly on Saturday to Sochi for a weekend with Putin. Steven Lee Myers contributed reporting for this article.
