I think there should be a differance. Naming cinelerra-cv is appropriate. I'd like to use cinelerra4 but can't get it to build on my gentoo box. If somebody want's to maintain upstream heroines on gentoo it should be available as cinelerra. D
On Thu, Aug 21, 2008 at 10:12 AM, Raffaella Traniello < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Ciao! > > Hanno Böck wrote: > The gentoo package of cinelerra community version was named > cinelerra-cvs in the past. As it's no longer cvs and "original > cinelerra" (hv version) has been removed long time ago, we've > now renamed the package to plain cinelerra. > We had a discussion about that (and cinelerra-cv was suggested), > but for me, two reasons spoke for cinelerra: > a) other distros use this name as well > b) cinelerra community version is the only cinelerraversion > maintained today. > I want people to get something when they type in emerge > cinelerra > > mskala wrote: > Given that there is no other cinelerra package available for > Gentoo, I think it's perfectly reasonable (fair and right) to > use the name "cinelerra" for the only cinelerra package that > exists. However, if the system supports it (and I imagine it > does) it'd probably be best for this to be done through some > kind of aliasing mechanism - just like you can probably install > something called "kernel" and get "kernel-2.6.19.123.foo", maybe > there could be a package called > "cinelerra" that currently gives you "cinelerra-cv" but could be > easily switched to some other cinelerra at such time as there is > one. > > The situation of Cinelerra for Ubuntu makes me think at this issue > again. > Since long time Ubuntu has packages for both CinelerraCV and > CinelerraHV. And now we can enjoy even an official HV Ubuntu package. > > Personally I'm really in favour for differentiating the versions on > every distro using different names: > 'cinelerra' > 'cinelerra-cv' > > For distros with no 'cinelerra' package, I like mskala's suggestion of > automatic switching to 'cinelerra-cv'. > > What are the cons of this proposal? > > Ciao > Raffaella > > > _______________________________________________ > Cinelerra mailing list > [email protected] > https://init.linpro.no/mailman/skolelinux.no/listinfo/cinelerra >
