Adrian Chadd wrote: > On Mon, Jan 14, 2008, Seth Mattinen wrote: >> I have a HWIC-4ESW module with POE. I'm pretty new to this module, so >> forgive my ignorance if I'm missing something totally obvious. =) >> >> Let's say I have ports Fa0/1/0, Fa0/1/1, and a subint on onboard Fa0/0.3 >> that's a dot1q VLAN to an external switch. (Fa0/0 has two tagged >> subinterfaces.) Is it possible to join the etherswitch ports to the VLAN >> on Fa0/0.3? Fallback bridging complains because it's a subint on Fa0/0. >> My goal is to use the module to drive some wireless access points. >> >> I have been using an SVI for the etherswitch ports and routing all the >> wireless traffic in from their own network, but I was wondering if >> there's a way to keep it all layer 2 instead. > > Nope. Well, short from connecting the onboard L3 port into a port on the > HWIC; which is probably not what you desire. > > I'd also benchmark the HWIC throughput and make sure you can drive the > WAP's across the HWIC interconnect. I forget what the throughput is like > for each integrated switch module, but you may find yourself thoroughly > disappointed. Their L2 performance is fine, but when you start wanting > to talk router -> hwic ports the interconnect becomes a problem. > (This is why people loop an onboard l3 router port into a port on the > HWIC in some circumstances.) > >
Ah, I figured as much. I *did* try connecting a port from the switch to a port on the HWIC, (Fa0/0 <-trunk-> switch <-untagged-> Fa0/1/0) but it had problems; a wifi client could ping other devices on the switch, but not any IP on the router itself or anything that needed to be routed through the router (i.e. Fa0/1 to the world or a t1 to a branch office). I'm guessing it was an arp problem, but as I said, my experience with these things are quite limited. SVI it is, then. Luckily I have the luxury of telling the wireless users in this case that if they want performance, they need to go find a wall jack and the wireless is for convenience only. ~Seth _______________________________________________ cisco-nsp mailing list [email protected] https://puck.nether.net/mailman/listinfo/cisco-nsp archive at http://puck.nether.net/pipermail/cisco-nsp/
