On Fri, 26 Nov 2021 01:54:47 GMT, Sergey Bylokhov <s...@openjdk.org> wrote:
>> Done. thank you very much. > > I few questions to thinking about: > - If the label and icon is not accessible then should we say something? Or > we should ignore it like we do for any other non-accessible components? > - Why the image text is used, don't we need to use the > "javax.accessibility.AccessibleRole#ICON" role for such label/icon and allow > the reader to say something standard for the icon. Does the voiceover has > some default text for the icon/image when the alt text is not set? Thank you very much. We've made a change. A comparison of the behavior before and after the changes is below. ### On MAcOS. #### State before our changes .: - in a standalone label with an icon without text, VO says Image; - in a standalone label with an icon with text VO speaks the text of the label; - If a label without text with an icon is in the table VO says "Empty cell". #### If you add just a role change: - in a standalone label with an icon without text, VO says Image; - in a standalone label with an icon with text VO speaks the text of the label; - In the table for a label with an icon without text, when navigating horizontally, VO does not say anything; - In the table for a label with an icon without text for vertical navigation, VO says "image cell". Unacceptable option. #### With a complete fix: - in a standalone label with an icon without text, VO says Image; - in a standalone label with an icon with text VO speaks the text of the label; - In the table for a label with an icon without text, for any navigation, VO says "image". ### ON Windows. #### State before our changes: - in a standalone label with an icon and text, the label text is spoken; - in a standalone label with an icon without text, the label is skipped; - In the table, a label with an icon without text is not spoken, the column heading is spoken. #### With full patch: - in a standalone label with an icon and text, the label text is spoken; - in a standalone label with an icon without text the "Image icon" is spoken; - In the table, a label with an icon without text is pronounced as "Image". ------------- PR: https://git.openjdk.java.net/jdk/pull/6538
