On Tue, 7 Oct 2025 10:40:19 GMT, Alexey Ivanov <[email protected]> wrote:
>>> I tested SizeMinimizedTest.java running in CI and no failure is observed. >>> It's true that I had added the test for different bug ID long time which is >>> wrong. Should we just move it to another JBS and PL it while removing >>> 8305915 PL ? I guess we should handle both the issue separately with >>> different BugID ? >> >> At the very least, this info should be added to the current JBS issue. Maybe >> update the title and the summary of the issue to also include the removal of >> `SizeMinimizedTest.java` from the PL. > >> > As @DamonGuy mentioned, a better way to deal with >> > [JDK-8305915](https://bugs.openjdk.org/browse/JDK-8305915) could be >> > closing it as _Cannot reproduce_ and submitting a new bug to update >> > `FrameLocation.java` and remove `SizeMinimizedTest.java` from the problem >> > list. >> >> Probably I'll capture screenshot on failure and deproblemlist it. If I close >> the bug as _Cannot reproduce_ then it remains in problem listing, so better >> way is to de-problemlist it and add screen capture. > > That's the point—you cannot reproduce the failure of `FrameLocation.java`, > can you? > > Thus, the correct resolution is *Cannot Reproduce*. > > Adding a screenshot is not fixing the failure reported in > [JDK-8305915](https://bugs.openjdk.org/browse/JDK-8305915), it's an > improvement for the test to have the more information to analyse the failure > if it occurs again. This is why it's a new issue. > > 8305915 has to be removed from the PL, submit a new bug, or rather create a > subtask of JDK-8305915, to remove both `FrameLocation.java` and > `SizeMinimizedTest.java` from the problem list. > > I strongly believe this approach creates a clearer bug history in JBS and > clearer changelog in the JDK. This also makes backporting easier as well as > dealing with test failures in older releases. > > Yes, submitting two new bugs creates more work but we're not in a rush here, > and I think *it's worth the time*. > > I can submit the bugs for you if you prefer so. @aivanov-jdk @DamonGuy I've raised https://github.com/openjdk/jdk/pull/27678 PR for de-problemlisting the main bug. Once this is integrated, I'll close the main bug as "Not-Reproducible". ------------- PR Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jdk/pull/27366#issuecomment-3377713390
