On Fri, Oct 5, 2012 at 11:15 AM, Alex Huang <alex.hu...@citrix.com> wrote: >> Alex, >> >> A couple of issues. >> >> First, we shouldn't be voting on the "beta" release artifacts. I need to >> cut a >> proper 4.0.0 build for us to vote on. >> >> Second, there are still several bugs that I consider to be blockers >> outstanding >> right now. >> >> Unfortunately, my vote is -1 for this VOTE thread, based on the reasons >> above. > > Chip, > > Can you cut a proper build? This is for a first round of voting. I don't > expect the first round to pass but I like to put all this out there for > people to test. I understand a few bugs came in last night but I think the > product is largely ready for people to test because QA testing is at 93% > complete yesterday. > > After Wednesday discussion on IRC, I realized we should have been doing this > already. Technically we're really at fourth or fifth round now because QA > has been taking builds and testing and has been in effect voting -1 on the > release. I've been running it like a enterprise-like release process and > that's my fault for doing so. > > I think the next few rounds will come very quickly because we're only going > to fix the blockers that we've found. > > --Alex >
Alex, Great explanation of your intent. Thanks. I just sent out specifics that are causing my -1 vote. I'd like to see that we make some progress on those bugs before starting another vote thread though... I think that we can use this current thread to find other people's concerns. If we make a bunch of progress on the bugs I listed today, I don't disagree with cutting a 4.0.0 version build and restarting a vote this afternoon. Fair?
