At 16:06 28.11.2001, Berin wrote: >Torsten Curdt wrote: > > >>>Hm, nice to hear "you are right", but did I say that? I feel making >>>this configurable is FS. > >Perhaps we need to distinguish the type of redirection we are expecting >by having two methods on the Redirector object: > >redirect() >globalRedirect() > >The only difference is during the aggregation. If someone is using >aggregation as a means of keeping menu and content separate on their >system, they want the redirect to load an entirely different page. >If the redirect is part of a portal, then only the local piece needs >to be redirected. > >The problem is that the current form of Aggregation is not flexible >enough to do portal aggregation effectively. +1 for make it a little bit more flexible i had posted a patch (2 times the last for about 3 Weeks) for the sidemap to use the select statement in aggregation i think when in the aggregation select match and action functionality work the need for redirect where small when out of this components a redirect is invoked that can be seen as a globalRedirect()
>The normal redirect() function works exacly like now (i.e. if the >resource is global, redirect to a whole new resource, and if a >resource is a map:part, only the local part is redirected). > >The globalRedirect() function works to redirect the entire resource >all the time. That way, everybody gets what they want with a simple >solution that is both semantically correct, and that does not add >additional complexity to the most complex beast within Cocoon: the >sitemap. This way we avoid FS but maintain flexibility with well > >defined contracts. > > > >>Well, alright, this was more a... both have a point so let's make it configurable ;) >>Sorry, I laid the words in your mouth :) >>(OT: native speakers - is this the correct phrase?) > > >The correct phrase is: "I put the words in your mouth" Klaus --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
