An unspecified "millet" in a line of pasta produced by a Rockford, Maryland company/1 led me to the question: Which millet makes the best noodle? I found that the question might be better framed as which millet is best for or with what. All that reminded me of the lack of comparative taste tests of millets,a topic I haven't brought up on this list in a while./2
Before getting to what I found, it's worth mentioning that the oldest evidence of millets in noodles dates back to the Qijia culture 4000 years ago in what is now Qinghai province in China. Analysis of preserved remains concluded that they were made with a mix of foxtail and proso millets /3 Searching online, I thought that the most interesting of very few examples is that from the Millet Me company (based in Mumbai, India)./4 They ranked 10 of their own products made with different ingredients, including pearl millet, finger millet, foxtail millet, and sorghum, along with the three pseudo-cereals (quinoa, buckwheat, and amaranth), rice, black beans, and soba (typically a mix of buckwheat and wheat). They emphasize that the top ranks are most versatile, and the bottom ranks are just more limited in what the testers thought they went with. Another company, Vasudha Foods, evaluated noodles made with foxtail millet, finger millet, pearl millet, kodo millet, little millet, and sorghum./5 This isn't really a ranking, but they also make the point that not all kinds of millet noodles go with every dish. Some references here also to Ayurvedic classifications. Most other links in a search for noodles made with different millets don't really discuss the topic in any breadth - some just comparing "millet" to wheat in noodles. While millets in general may share some characteristics (generally higher in fiber and sometimes nutrients; lack of gluten, which not only is of interest to those with celiac disease, but also affects physical characteristics of the noodles), they are different enough to merit discussing or referencing individually On the broader topic of comparing tastes of millets, I found one particularly interesting article on the Chef's Pencil site comparing 11 millets: pearl millet; finger millet; proso millet; foxtail millet; barnyard millet; little millet; kodo millet; browntop millet; white fonio; black fonio; and Guinea millet./6 This does not appear to be the result of side-by-side comparisons, and it is not clear that the authors have sampled all of them. This is actually a very nice summary, although as previously discussed, Guinea millet may have ceased to be cultiated./7 However, when this Chef's Pencil article moves to specific examples of uses of millets, it unfortunately reverts to the generic "millet." You have to be familiar with the regions and the uses to know which millet is used for what (my suggestions in parentheses). For example: * "Persian Layered Rice with Millet, Nuts & Fruits" (likely proso) * "Akoumé" (made with flour of pearl millet or corn/maize; when I was in Togo, the former was more common in the north, and the latter in the south) * "Turkish Boza" (proso) * "Millet in West African Cooking" (as a rule, this would be pearl millet; finger millet is less cultivated in this region compared to east and southern Africa) Finally, an article on formal research involving blind taste texts into how 9 varieties of millets work in various culinary contexts: finger millet; pearl millet; white and yellow sorghum; little millet; barnyard millet; proso millet; kodo millet; and browntop millet./8 I think that this approach would be the ideal to adapt to evaluating potentisl uses of millets in foods familiar to most consumers in North America. Short of that, however, it would still be interesting for the data and publicity to somehow arrange for blind taste tests of millets, say as cooked grains (plain) and in some kind of noodle or small baked product. Perhaps at a major food conference? Easy to suggest, but obviously assembling the resources and people needed to pull off such an experiment would be a challenge. Don Osborn, PhD (East Lansing, MI, US) North American Millets Alliance Notes: 1. Organic Proshop sells macaroni, ramen, and rotini made with "millet flour." https://www.organicproshop.com/ This is probably proso, but I'm writing to verify. 2. "A bowl of 4,000 year-old noodle," by CH'NG Poh Tiong, Decanter China, 10 Sep 2013 https://www.decanterchina.com/en/columns/chng-poh-tiongs-column-zuo-wang/a-bowl-of-4-000-year-old-noodle 3. https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/search?mlist=collab%40lists.millets2023.space&q=%22taste+tests%22 4. "We Ranked Every Millet Me Noodle, Honestly (Including the Ones That Aren't for Everyone)," Millet Me, 22 Sep 2026 https://www.milletme.com/blogs/news/we-ranked-every-millet-me-noodle-honestly-including-the-ones-that-arent-for-everyone 5. "6 Types of Millet Noodles Available Online in India: Foxtail, Finger, Pearl, Kodo, Little, and Sorghum Explained," Vasudha Foods, 19 Jun 2026 https://www.vasudhafoods.com/blogs/resources/6-types-of-millet-noodles-available-online-in-india-foxtail-finger-pearl-kodo-little-and-sorghum-explained 6. "11 Types of Millet: Flavors, Textures, and How to Use Them," Chef's Pencil, 17 Sep 2026 https://www.chefspencil.com/11-types-of-millet-flavors-textures-and-how-to-use-them/ 7. "Is Guinea millet a lost crop?" Don Osborn, Collab, 21 Sep 2025 https://lists.millets2023.space/archives/list/[email protected]/message/56GNHA5BSCXLMMM3M6RZQG3IHNO3R4JY/ 8. Anitha S, Arjun P, Palli NC, Sreekanth N, Miruthika Devi SA, Pandey S, Krishnan S, Prasad S, Sharma S, Chidambara Murthy KN, Botha R, Upadhyay S, and Kane-Potaka J (2024) "Sensory and nutritional evaluation of nine types of millet substituted for polished white rice in select Indian meal preparations." Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 8:1331260. doi: 10.3389/fsufs.2024.1331260 https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/sustainable-food-systems/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2024.1331260/full -- Collab mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
