.................................
To leave Commie, hyper to
http://commie.oy.com/commie_leaving.html
.................................

>Mac OS X beta interface tour:
>http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/intro.html

Some OS X anti-hype by me:


Mac OS X System Preferences:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/2.html

Looks bad to me. Especially the sentence "these items are all 
Apple-supplied, and third parties don't get to drop their own 
controls in this application".

It's really easy to use the current Mac OS control panels. Control 
Panels folder is just a similar folder like all the other folders. If 
you don't need - let's say - "Sound" control panel, you just drag the 
panel out of the folder and restart. The panels reserve less memory 
after restart and the machine works a bit faster.

The best part is, that anyone can make system-wide third party 
control panels. It's very clear and simple: If the control panel 
affects the whole system, you'll find it in the Control Panels 
folder... Too bad, if they're tossing this great feature by OS X...


Login Items:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/4.html

Well, I'm not absolutely convinced, whether it's a good idea to make 
different kinds of interfaces for every basic level functionality you 
have... In current Mac OS, the applications that should be run during 
the startup, can be just dragged and dropped to a folder called 
"Startup Items" (inside System Folder). Most of the feel of "ease of 
use" in current Mac OS comes from this: all the functionality follows 
the same logic.


Sharing:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/6.html

This is definitely a good thing: Goodbye AppleTalk! It sucks!


Window Fade:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/7.html

One question: Where you can turn it off?


HTML.Edit:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/11.html

This looks promising: A wysiwyg HTML editor shipped with the 
operating system...


Open dialog:
http://macworld.zdnet.com/2000/09/13/tour/12.html

There are two interface elements that does the same job in this 
window: The popup menu that tell you where you are (like in current 
Mac OS) and the leftmost column... This is Windows-logic: "Let's put 
all the possibilities there, because we're not quite sure, which one 
is the best..." ... and the user will _never_ learn the logic of your 
user interface (because there isn't any logic in it...)

Then again, the text field, where you can directly write the path of 
the file to be opened, is a good improvement, imho. Very often it's 
faster to just write the path. Currently... I've ended up using 
Sherlock (the search tool of Mac OS) for just opening files. I 
usually remember, where they are located, but it's faster to write 
the file name into Sherlock and open the file from there (by 
double-clicking the icon) than surf the hard disk with the cumbersome 
Open dialog...


-- 

---> jab | commie
       listen at http://166.90.148.110:6136,
       set up at http://commie.oy.com/radio.html

Reply via email to