ferruzzi commented on issue #8544:
URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow/issues/8544#issuecomment-800643763


   I've started putting down the boilerplate code, I think this is how I am 
going to tackle this.  I'm not sure how formal you folks like it yet, but 
please let me know what you think of the plan.
   
   ### Goals
   
   Add a collection of Apache Airflow Operators which interact with Amazon 
Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS) and abstract all Amazon logic from the Airflow 
user.  This will allow Airflow to be a general purpose Kubernetes orchestrator 
able to do multi-cluster orchestration across multiple clouds.
   
   ### Proposal
   
   The proposed solution is a collection of Operators, and their underlying 
Hooks, which will be added to the Amazon AWS provider package.  These Operators 
will handle creating and deleting clusters, as well as executing tasks using 
EKS Managed Node Groups.  
   
   ### Assumptions and Prerequisites
   
   * The account running the DAGs will need eks:DescribeCluster IAM permissions 
to retrieve the information currently provided by the manual kubeconfig file.
   
   ### Definitions
   
   *Pod* - A Kubernetes *pod* is the way that Kubernetes runs containers on a 
compute instance and includes containers and specifications for how they should 
run, networking, and storage. A *pod* can be a single container or multiple 
containers that always run together.
   
   *Cluster* - An Amazon EKS *cluster* consists of the Amazon EKS control 
plane, which runs the Kubernetes software and API server, and the *pod* that is 
registered with the control plane.
   
   *Operator* - An *operator* defines a single task within the workflow.
   
   *kubectl* - The Kubernetes command-line tool which allows users to run 
commands against Kubernetes clusters. Uses include deploying applications, 
inspecting and managing cluster resources, and viewing logs.
   
   *eksctl* - An open source CLI tool created by the community to create 
clusters on EKS using CloudFormation.
   
   *aws eks (cli tool)* - A CLI tool which, among other things, is used to 
generate the kubeconfig file.
   
   *kubeconfig* - A config file containing required information about clusters, 
users, namespaces, and authentication mechanisms. *kubectl* uses *kubeconfig* 
files to find the information it needs to choose a cluster and communicate with 
the API server of a cluster.
   
   *EKS Managed Node Groups* (nodegroup) - Infrastructure as a Service - *EKS 
Managed Node Groups* create and manage Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2) 
instances which host a Kubernetes cluster.  This is the default underlying 
compute platform for EKS clusters. 
   
   *Task* - The process or command being run in a pod.
   
   
   ### Context and User Experience
   
   While the basic functions of creating and running pods on EKS can be handled 
through the existing Cloud Native Computing Foundation (CNCF) Kubernetes Pod 
Operator, running the pods on EKS introduces pain points to the users, some of 
which are detailed below, and requires some specific EKS knowledge.  By 
abstracting away some of this Amazon-specific logic, we can automate and 
streamline the configuration and deployment of new pods.
   
   Currently, in order to deploy a new pod on EKS, the user needs to leverage 
the kubectl, eksctl, and aws command-line tools and generate config files to 
manually pass data to the Kubernetes Pod Operator.  The current manual process 
is:
   
   1. Create a cluster - uses the eksctl CLI tool
   2. Create a namespace - uses the kubectl CLI tool
   3. Create and attach an IAM Role for permission to log into the cluster - 
uses eksctl CLI tool
   4. Create or modify the Airflow requirements.txt file to ensure it contains 
two required packages: awscli and kubernetes==12.0.1
   5. Create and possibly edit the kubeconfig file - uses aws eks CLI tool
   6. Copy the edited kubeconfig file to the dags directory
   
   
   Using the BOTO3 python API, new Operators can automate most or all of those 
steps and create a more seamless experience for the user.
   
   ### Use Cases
   Use Case # | Short Description | Priority | Supporting Operator
   -- | -- | -- | --
   1 | As a user, I want to create a new cluster using existing pods. | 0 | 
Create Cluster
   2 | As a user, I want to be able to delete a cluster I have created. | 0 | 
Delete Cluster
   3 | As a user, I want to execute a new task on my existing pod. | 0 | Start 
Pod
   4 | As a user, I want to delete a pod that I created on a nodegroup. | 0 | 
Delete Nodegroup
   5 | As a user, I want to create a new pod using managed nodegroups. | 0 | 
Create Nodegroup
   
   Benchmarks
   
   At a minimum, this solution should offer feature parity with the Google 
Kubernetes Engine (GKE) Pod Operator functionality.
   
   **Create Cluster** - Create a Google Kubernetes Engine Cluster of specified 
dimensions
   
   ```
   operator = GKEClusterCreateOperator(
                   task_id='cluster_create',
                   project_id='my-project',
                   location='my-location',
                   body=cluster_def,)
   ```
   
   **Delete Cluster** - Deletes the cluster, including the Kubernetes endpoint 
and all worker nodes
   
   ```
   operator = GKEClusterDeleteOperator(
                   task_id='cluster_delete',
                   project_id='my-project',
                   location='cluster-location',
                   name='cluster-name',)
   ```
   
   
   **Start Pod** - Executes a task in a Kubernetes pod in the specified Google 
Kubernetes Engine cluster
   
   ```
    operator = GKEStartPodOperator(
                   task_id="pod_task",
                   project_id=GCP_PROJECT_ID,
                   location=GCP_LOCATION,
                   cluster_name=CLUSTER_NAME,
                   namespace="default",
                   image="perl",
                   name="test-pod",)
   ```
   
   And some sequence diagrams for the Operators for folks who like that kinda 
thing:
   
   ![Create Cluster](https://i.imgur.com/qXyBjgd.png)
   ![Delete Cluster](https://i.imgur.com/dtCv1al.png)
   ![Start Pod](https://i.imgur.com/pwiLvqV.png)


----------------------------------------------------------------
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.

For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]


Reply via email to