potiuk commented on issue #27674: URL: https://github.com/apache/airflow/issues/27674#issuecomment-1323396660
@alexott - Also to explain more (and apologise, if it's been a little - or even little more than a little - harsh). But I think this is really just question of balance between the risk we will break something and the time/effort of somone's (who?) to do enough testiing to be confident envouhg. There is never 100%. We cannot extend the testing period for very long time because it will hamper our "operations". And we do not know who is / is not available for testing. We cannot really have a point to say "we wait for response". The most we can do is to make all the reasonable effort to flag and notify everyone involved and give them SOME time to react. Is 72 hours enough? Should it be 96 maybe? Should we always have weekend included? To be honest I was quite surprised to see the statement of yours - usually we made voting last 1 more day if the weekend was included to account that people will NOT have time to do testing then because usually they spend weekends with their families etc. I often (my personal choice) do some CI stuff during wekends because then it's faster and safer to iterate on it) and quite often I shift my working/non-working days freely because I have very flexible situation (no day job, no kids, wife that has also super flexible schedule), but I would not think this is "needed" by others :) Do you really think having a weekend as part of the voting time for providers is a good idea and way to improve the quality of testing in general? I think we COULD make sure we always start voting on Wed and finish on Tuesday, I just have feeling that would be rather artifficial setting for one specific case only. I often did adjust the relase schedule to various events (for example I would never start voting this Wednesday - knowing that ThanksGiving is coming),. Maybe this is also question to others in this thread. We have quite representative group in this thread - do you think that would be a good idea to add some regularity in the day-of-week process? -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
